VVD asks parliamentary questions

Possible departure of HZPC to US shakes up politics

9 March 2017 - Clarisse van der Woude - 13 comments

The possible transfer of HZPC's breeding techniques to the United States is shaking up politics. The VVD asked parliamentary questions on Wednesday.

Director Gerard Backx said during the Potatoes Theme Day in Dronten in February that as long as potato breeders are not allowed to use breeding techniques such as cisgenesis or Cripr-Cas in Europe, he may be moving the research to the United States. 'The technology is wrongly linked to genetic modification. No politician wants to burn his hands on that. You don't make yourself popular with such topics. Banning things to advance food safety is welcome, but as soon as there is even a hint of doubt…', Backx explains.

If gene research is not possible here, but can be done in the US, we will do our work in the US

The discussion has now been going on for eight years. Nevertheless, at the end of 2016 a motion exempting the biotechnological technique Crispr-Cas from the strict requirements that apply to genetic modification was passed by a majority of the House of Representatives.

To date, however, there has been no decision from the cabinet. However, Backx's statement has put the subject back on the agenda, because VVD MP Remco Bosma has Parliamentary questions asked.

Bosma asks the State Secretary for Economic Affairs, among other things, whether he shares the concerns that the departure of these departments will cause the Netherlands to experience an enormous bloodletting and thus effectively end the top sector policy. He repeatedly wants to know whether there is a proactive attitude to retain the industry. He also discusses the technology itself.

Although HZPC's plans are not yet concrete and the director first wants to wait for the political outcome, he is serious. 'If it definitively turns out that we cannot do this gene research here, but in the US, then we will do our work in the US. We put our own people there or we outsource it to an institute or university.'

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know
Comments
13 comments
top 9 March 2017
This is a response to this article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness.nl/aardappelen/ artikel/10873726/Possible-departure-HZPC-naar-VS-schudt-politics-wakker]Possible departure of HZPC to the US shakes up politics[/url]
I wouldn't wait for politics, you can't rely on that anyway.
herb 10 March 2017
Yes, just keep going.
We have to stay ahead
Arnold 10 March 2017
As a sector you have to listen to your consumer. If the consumer has arguments, you have to take them seriously, sometimes they are mainly emotional and sometimes rational. When we look at public health and see (or don't want to see) the developments, we have to start asking ourselves, do they have a point and if so, we should take them into account. If not, we should be able to convince them. We mustn't forget to ask ourselves what underlies the rising health care costs, as a professor at a medical school put it this way, "85% of diseases and ailments are food-related". Could the fact that we have strayed too far from natural thinking in our starting points, dictated by the financial world, lie at the root of the growing sick and very bad? Scientific reports clearly point in this direction. Let us learn from dairy farming and not try to prove us right with false arguments, the truth comes back like a boomerang and will work enormously against the sector. The problems that are outlined must be solved in a natural way. It is possible only it requires a different way of thinking. This creates social support and that gives a strategic market position.
top 10 March 2017
The consumer is like a pig, if he pulls his tail he wants to move forward, pulling his head doesn't help either, he wants to go backwards. Convincing a pig of something also makes little sense, all a pig wants is to eat a lot without having to do anything for it.
Consumer 10 March 2017
And what are you already consuming the best?
peta 11 March 2017
Arnold wrote:
As a sector you have to listen to your consumer. If the consumer has arguments, you have to take them seriously, sometimes they are mainly emotional and sometimes rational. When we look at public health and see (or don't want to see) the developments, we have to start asking ourselves, do they have a point and if so, we should take them into account. If not, we should be able to convince them. We mustn't forget to ask ourselves what underlies the rising health care costs, as a professor at a medical school put it this way, "85% of diseases and ailments are food-related". Could the fact that we have strayed too far from natural thinking in our starting points, dictated by the financial world, lie at the root of the growing sick and very bad? Scientific reports clearly point in this direction. Let us learn from dairy farming and not try to prove us right with false arguments, the truth comes back like a boomerang and will work enormously against the sector. The problems that are outlined must be solved in a natural way. It is possible only it requires a different way of thinking. This creates social support and that gives a strategic market position.

As long as in arable farming the 'advisors' are actually chemistry salesmen, nothing will change in the thinking of the masses of arable farmers! The government has a task here to investigate and demonstrate alternatives more deeply. In the countries around us, such as France, Germany and Switzerland, people are much more active in this and also further than in the 'knowledge country' the Netherlands!
Arnold 11 March 2017
Great, if you think that way about the consumer, or have experienced it that way, I wonder how you have dealt with the consumer. I wonder if you understand the gist of my piece, I think you have to guess yourself.
Petatje, your start is good, the observation is correct, but you have your own responsibility and free entrepreneurial choice, hopefully from a clear vision. no, forget it, our politics has very different interests and still has its head in the clouds. And you know it when you are in the clouds you have little visibility. And insight into many things is necessary to develop a good vision. As an entrepreneur, you can outline a policy based on a clear vision and you will get there.
Willy 11 March 2017
Nonsense discussion
top 11 March 2017
Arnold, I can conclude that you never go outside the Netherlands or Europe, because then you would have had a better idea of ​​reality.
Arnold 11 March 2017
Great, I've been to many countries, not only on vacation but also business contacts, and I gave my eyes and ears a good living. Participates in networks where parties are present that help set up international projects, so knows quite a bit about what is for sale. Also know the possibilities and the threats. But if I have something to sell, a few things are important to me, a. Treat your consumer with respect, b. Ask what his needs are. c. Try to have a distinctive product, preferably above his standards, you will notice how much he wants your product. And if he knows how to appreciate that distinctive quality, you are a merchant. If not, it's a matter of supply and demand, you don't fit together and you have to say goodbye. What's the problem?
Jan Veltkamp 11 March 2017
Unfortunately; the question in the article is whether we want to keep HZPC for NL. The discussion is mostly about the emotional decision-making of the consumer/end consumer and not about HZPC. It should be noted (at least that's how I read it) not the entire HZPC disappears but (only??) their research on specific products.
top 11 March 2017
First, HZPC will move the research to the US or Canada, which already has a branch. From there, of course, the breeding and eventually the first propagation will take place, since the cost price there is simply lower than in NL. It should not be forgotten that the interest of the HZPC certificate holders is great to make a profit, this is a different interest than what might suit the NL growers. After all, you can't get 2 backs out of 1 pig.
Jan 11 March 2017
@top, And that is why it is good that many certificates are in the hands of growers and that the other holders are well disposed towards the growers.
The grower-certificate holders also have an interest in the profit that HZPC makes with other than physical seed potato turnover.
top 12 March 2017
Indeed, certificates can give NL growers more future than the cultivation itself.
You can no longer respond.

What do the current
potato quotations?

View and compare prices and rates yourself

News Potatoes

HZPC expects to break million ton barrier

News Potatoes

HZPC keeps volume almost the same but sees profit decline

News Potatoes

Dairy boss Hans Huistra starts as new CEO of HZPC

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register