Shutterstock

News Crop protection

Minister does not support extension of desmedifam

15 May 2019 - Niels van der Boom - 28 comments

The SCoPAFF will meet on 20 and 21 May to discuss the regulation of plant protection products in the European Union. Minister Carola Schouten (Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality) will write on Wednesday 15 May which positions she will take. The extension of desmedipham, the active ingredient in Betanal, is not possible if it is up to her.

The European Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed (SCoPAFF) supports the European Commission in decision-making on various agricultural topics, including crop protection. The European Commission last year already know that there is no majority to extend the active ingredient desmedifam, to which the European beet sector reacted with dismay.

Ctgb negative
In Letter to Parliament let her know that the Board for the Authorization of Plant Protection Products and Biocides (Ctgb) also advises her not to renew the approval. This is due to concerns about 'carcinogenic and reprotoxic properties'. Desmedipham is said to have a hormone-disrupting effect. The delegation therefore intends to agree to the proposal not to renew the extension.

After the European Commission's position was announced last year, the European beet growers' organization CIBE sounded the alarm. They called for letters to be sent urging that desmedipham, along with phenmedipham, are crucial for weed control in sugar beets. The Commission considered that there was not enough opposition from the sector. Suiker Unie supported the CIBE initiative.

Cost increase
Betanal is seen by many growers as the backbone in beet weed control, and is therefore much needed according to growers. A ban means that more must be combated mechanically. With a view to increasing costs, this is not seen as a positive development, certainly with the current beet prices and expectations for the crop. More details about the phasing out of desmedipham have not yet been announced.

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Niels van der Boom

Niels van der Boom is a senior market specialist for arable crops at DCA Market Intelligence. He mainly makes analyses and market updates about the potato market. In columns he shares his sharp view on the arable sector and technology.
Comments
28 comments
applicant 15 May 2019
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness.nl/akkerbouw/ artikel/10882488/minister-staat-niet-achter-slangen-desmedifam]Minister does not support extension of desmedifam[/url]
Of course she says no, because she has nothing to do with agriculture. Moreover, she will then have a better chance of becoming alderman in Amsterdam, just like her predecessor. Cozy with the crazy green mayor.
beet farmer 15 May 2019
drone
Subscriber
Skirt 15 May 2019
Again confirmation of the destruction of NL agriculture. The train rumbles on, we are going to experience a lot more, things derail by themselves. Good luck everyone.
wcm 15 May 2019
Carol,
As a farmer's daughter, you should be ashamed of yourself for dropping this sector again and again.
Dirty your own nest, so they say. Very sad.
We don't have to expect anything more from you.
Time and again you drop the sector, just worthless.
Rejected.
Apply to be the president of a neighborhood association or tennis club, maybe better for you, but definitely better for us.

JH 16 May 2019
A government and society that treat its agricultural sector so disdainfully are not worth the food.
flaming 16 May 2019
And they can then raise the MRL on imported products, just like with neonicotinoids.
neighbour 16 May 2019
Do not understand that we farmers let all this come over us, must stop once this can not continue with peasant pests have to stand up for ourselves.
Subscriber
polder grower 16 May 2019
Beet growing is over, goodnight Carola.
Cosun , can also look for a buyer for scrap iron.
The factories can close.

Will we still get our long-awaited potato cooperative, because beets will no longer be grown in the Netherlands..
Skirt 16 May 2019
Potatoes go after beets, diquat, finale, etc
truth 16 May 2019
Id it will be empty bare run-down places in rural areas farmers gone criminals take over the empty stables because everyone has to become vegan (Boxtel) etc etc
funny 16 May 2019
After all, we all wanted a ministry of agriculture.
Hundreds of civil servants who are only concerned with our sector.
Maybe it wasn't so bad after all to get involved in economic affairs...
Wim 16 May 2019
It's crazy that they only find out after 10 years.
south farmer 17 May 2019
Mrs. Schouten has completely killed sugar beet cultivation. But indeed, as has been rightly stated, we wanted a ministry of agriculture so badly.... sigh.
Skirt 17 May 2019
In the other case, it would have ended up with the Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and the Environment, they are going to remediate agriculture anyway.
gerard 17 May 2019
I don't care if it's all over the EU. if it is a rule of the hague again we should go shopping abroad that is sometimes called civil disobedience
Thomas 17 May 2019
Didn't trust Schouten from the start and she is very left-wing. This is more and more a major setback for our beautiful agricultural sector by the day.
Frog 17 May 2019
I am curious whether our minister would also reject all medicines if she were to become ill, which would be in line with her policy.
jpk 17 May 2019
The Horse-Drawn Carriage Farming of Christian Union and D66. Result see pulse fishing agriculture is becoming a tourist sector
and now 19 May 2019
the measure is starting to get pretty full. maybe it's time to organize some tougher campaigns. some highways paralyze something like that
Peter 19 May 2019
Only expressing frustrations on this forum doesn't solve anything you will have to take action, like farmers in France, you have to enforce respect that you don't get a gift!!!!!,,,,,,,,,,they laugh with what you write in the hague!
??? !!! 19 May 2019
Farmers in France generally don't have my sympathy: fed-up leftist subsidy guzzlers. Possible damage to all that free money: complete overreaction right away.

Delivery stop. Empty shelves or factories that have to close: that works wonders. Just do not supply milk for three weeks: then most of the fresh milk will be used up.
organic farmer 19 May 2019
As an organic grower, it's easy for me to say, but the idea that the entire beet cultivation (and the entire agriculture) has already been written off seems to me to be too much. I see fairly normal beets around here. And names like "bitch" seem to me to be below the peasant dignity.
??? !!! 19 May 2019
indeed: organic growers have it easy with skal.
new label coming soon: really organic? We now know skal bio as common, but then fraud.
umbrella 19 May 2019
You are going to have a hard time organic farmer, now you are still hiding behind the neighbor's substance use! soon with a higher pressure from fungi and insects due to 100% organic waste in the Netherlands, it will no longer be easy to achieve a yield. And look once again to find enough Eastern Europe employees for all that weeding when we all fish in that pond.
Narcos 19 May 2019
With their #doesnormal tractor action, farmers have shown that they are ready with that left-wing talk and are willing to take action themselves to stop this nonsense.
Also applies to the government, fuck your farmers and you will get the lid on your nose.
Here and there are already being called to put the matter neatly flat.
Perhaps some common sense will float to the top in those vegan organic cups.
JH 19 May 2019
Totally agree, a government and society that treats its agricultural sector with inferiority are only worth contempt. Certainly no organic food..
organizations 19 May 2019
daffodil is right. hard work is being done on an organized shutdown of all distribution centers of the supermarket chains. for a long time. Let's see what it feels like to have empty shelves in the supermarket. #farmersearningrespect #thegovernmentnaaitdeboer
Finally 21 May 2019
I would like to sign up to help organize. I can not wait. It's really time we showed that we don't let people walk all over us
You can no longer respond.

Sign up for our newsletter

Sign up and receive the latest news in your inbox every day

News Arable

German farmers fear huge yield losses

News Potatoes

Disappearance of Talent a bloodletting for the sector

Background Crop protection

'Ctgb passed over in ruling on lily cultivation'

News Crop protection

France relaxes crop protection policy

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register