Shutterstock

News Organic

Switching less attractive for German farmers

28 December 2022 - Linda van Eekeres - 7 comments

The prices that organic farmers receive for their products will have risen significantly less quickly in 2022 than is the case for conventional products. As a result, the economic incentive for German farmers to switch has decreased over the past year, the Deutscher Bauernverband writes in its annual report. This while the German government has the ambition to increase the share of organic acreage to 2030% by 30, almost tripling.

At the end of 2021, there were 36.300 organic farms (14%) in Germany with a total area of ​​more than 1,8 million hectares. In 2011 this was still 7,5% of the farms. The share of organic agricultural land in the total area has increased to 2021% in 10,9 (10,3% a year earlier). In 2011 this was still 6,1%. The German government wants 2030% of agricultural land to be farmed organically by 30. Germany is very ambitious with this, the goal of the European Commission is a quarter of organic agricultural area in the EU. The Netherlands is aiming for 'only' 15%, but it should be added that according to CBS figures, 2021% of the acreage here was organic in 4. 

In 2022, the situation is completely different
At the end of last year there was still quite a lot of interest in conversion among German farmers. According to the German agricultural economic barometer of December 2021, 20% of German farmers were interested, especially in southern Germany. The farmers surveyed mentioned reasonable producer prices, assured purchase and sufficient financial resources as important conditions. Figures for this year are not known, but whether the enthusiasm is still so great remains to be seen.

Due to the high food prices, caused by the war in the Ukraine and the energy crisis, consumers are opting for cheaper products and discounters. "This is in stark contrast to the record year 2020, when the sale of organic food rose sharply as an indirect result of corona," said the farmers' union. "Consumers could hardly travel during the corona period, restaurants closed and the budget for groceries was correspondingly high. The situation will be completely different in 2022."

Due to a lower yield and a higher workload, organic farmers depend on higher producer prices and organic premiums to survive economically, according to the farmers' union. During the usually two-year transition phase of a farm from conventional to organic farming, there are also conversion costs that are only partially offset by government organic subsidies, which vary in size in the German federal states. In 2021, a total of €392 million was spent in Germany from funds from the European Union, the federal government and the Länder for the promotion of organic farming.

Economic incentive
Producer prices for organic food have risen significantly less in 2022 than for conventional food, according to the Deutscher Bauernverband. "The price differences between conventional and organic goods have narrowed in almost all areas. The economic incentive for conventional farmers to switch to organic farming has therefore decreased at the moment."

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Linda van Eekeres

Linda van Eekeres is co-writing editor-in-chief. She mainly focuses on macro-economic developments and the influence of politics on the agricultural sector.
Comments
7 comments
Subscriber
economist 28 December 2022
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url = https: // www.boerenbusiness.nl/akkerbouw/artikel/10902267/switching-for-German-farmer-less-attractive]Switching less attractive for German farmers[/url]
everyone understands that. enforcing organic cultivation without a market is not going to work.

Let's take a look at the disadvantages of organic farming.

1. less yield, so less food
2. more crop failures, so a higher risk for the farmer, but also for the hungry citizen.
3. there is no labor available to do the manual work on the plots. already many abuses among foreign workers at organic farmers.
4th world pays a better price for our common agricultural products. think of powdered milk and chips. they don't want those by-products. too much risk of disease.
5. Organic farming is less sustainable than conventional farming.


good luck franske carpenter old climate dramer, green gnome
Subscriber
frog 29 December 2022
The biggest biodiversity killer is our own fat Frans with his biomass forest clearing.
Subscriber
gerard 29 December 2022
the first 2 are good things for the farmer if there is hunger that is good for the farmer because then there is more demand than supply
the hands that have to help are working hard on that with machines with cameras
oh yes I also prefer to spray I am a conventional arable farmer
normal 29 December 2022
nonsense machines with camera sounds nice but does not work.

remains manual work and that requires a lot of people

point 1 the people are not there / don't want to anymore

point 2 the wage costs simply cannot be paid from a red balance.

so stop with those wishful thinkers and reward the usual a bit more!
everyone benefits from safe/enough/affordable food, that's all it should be.
and don't try to bend this, dear people, because that costs tons of money and will never work
Subscriber
Southwest 29 December 2022
gerard wrote:
the first 2 are good things for the farmer if there is hunger that is good for the farmer because then there is more demand than supply
the hands that have to help are working hard on that with machines with cameras
oh yes I also prefer to spray I am a conventional arable farmer
If hunger comes is not good at all, then you don't understand the world. In the horn of Africa they are also hungry, which brings us nothing, because people don't have a penny to make. If you're hungry, there's more to it than everything is screwed up. With a full stomach, you can work and produce, you earn money and you can continue to buy food. With an empty stomach you die and then you can't and don't have to eat anymore.
Subscriber
sea ​​breeze 29 December 2022
Dear editor: send this article to one Jan Willem van der Berg of Ing-bank with the question: do something with it and come up with useful advice that I understand. Otherwise, resign from that position and become a peel farmer, which is a noble profession in the closed-loop approach. Then the RABO can include this in its model calculations after advice from Van der Wal-Indesloot
Subscriber
gerard 29 December 2022
if africa is so poor why are so many guns going to it
that's really not for charity
Africa is a treasure rich continent they have almost everything
money is distributed a bit strangely
but I mean in Europe if there is only a little short, the price already goes up
You can no longer respond.

What do the current
arable listings?

View and compare prices and rates yourself

Background Skin

'Skal has come a long way, but is not there yet'

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register