Agriphoto

News Crop protection

Stripe through the ban on spraying, but with restrictions

10 July 2023 - Niels van der Boom - 4 comments

The court in Leeuwarden ruled today (July 10) that a lily grower in Drenthe is allowed to apply plant protection products on his plots. In mid-June, great indignation arose within the agricultural sector when the judge in preliminary relief proceedings in Assen ruled against the grower forbade to use resources. A case about this was filed by local residents.

In particular, the fact that authorized plant protection products - approved by the Ctgb - apparently may not be used after all, is a hard blow for growers and agricultural entrepreneurs in general. This also applies to advocates such as the flower bulb organization KAVB and LTO. The Council judged this morning that the grower is allowed to carry out spraying again, but only allows four products.

Four resources
The fungicide Rudis, herbicides Titus and Goltix and Olie-H are the means that the grower must make do with according to the judge. Despite the fact that considerably more authorized products are available in lily cultivation, according to the ruling, this does not apply to this plot. According to the grower, the four resources mentioned are indispensable and are therefore permitted.

The appeal was lodged on Thursday, in which a decision was already made this morning because it concerns a 'turbo speed apple'. Further explanation is therefore still lacking. The case was brought by local residents of the lily plot in question because they fear for their health. The fact that the ban on spraying has now been lifted has caused great disappointment among residents.

Divisive mushroom
The lily industry is likely to breathe a sigh of relief with this small profit, even though not all restrictions have been lifted. There is a good chance that the last word has not yet been said on this divisive issue. Especially in the cultivation of lilies, the use of plant protection products remains a hot topic.

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Niels van der Boom

Niels van der Boom is a senior market specialist for arable crops at DCA Market Intelligence. He mainly makes analyses and market updates about the potato market. In columns he shares his sharp view on the arable sector and technology.

More about

Crop protection
Comments
4 comments
Subscriber
Zeeuw 10 July 2023
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url = https: // www.boerenbusiness.nl/akkerbouw/artikel/10905013/stripe-spraying-ban-but-with-restrictions]Strike through spraying ban, but with restrictions[/url]
Fortunately, not all of the legal power of the toad! Of course, chemical crop protection should be applied as little as possible and as carefully as possible. We also have rules and admission standards via Ctgb for this. It should not be the case that one judge with his 0,0 knowledge is going to pass judgment on that. Just as the Council of State does not elevate the so-called precautionary principle to legislation. Whether a municipality often applies “with a view to legalization”, ie there is no law or regulation, but we are making it. That is a mockery of democracy and a prelude to arbitrariness at the highest level. The Council of State, for example, is mainly D3 in color and is therefore proactive in all environmental issues. This omission in the legislation must be truncated quickly
Pieter 10 July 2023
Personally, I think it's only good that an independent judge looks at this now and then, without just assuming if a substance has been approved that it is safe to spray next to a residential area anyway. Whether something is safe often depends on many more factors.
Subscriber
redtide 11 July 2023
it is impossible for a judge to even have the necessary knowledge to rule on such complex matters, certainly not in such a short period of time.
Subscriber
Zeeuw 11 July 2023
Dear Pieter: you think the Ctbg are a bunch of wimps who only listen to the sector! Well, I can refresh you: they work less for the sector than the Council of State for D66. And I have had respect for the judges….!
You can no longer respond.

Sign up for our newsletter

Sign up and receive the latest news in your inbox every day

News Arable

German farmers fear huge yield losses

News Potatoes

Disappearance of Talent a bloodletting for the sector

Background Crop protection

'Ctgb passed over in ruling on lily cultivation'

News Crop protection

France relaxes crop protection policy

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register