Agriphoto

News Onions

VTA: '2019 seed onions harvest doubled'

17 September 2019 - Niels van der Boom - 11 comments

If we rely on the test harvesting figures for seed onions from the growers' organization VTA, the Dutch seed onion harvest amounts to 1,66 million tons. That is almost double the volume harvested last year. The VTA figures are on the multi-year average.

In September, a permanent group of VTA members carried out a trial harvesting of seed onions. This averages out at 59,6 tonnes per hectare, which is considerably more than the 41,4 tonnes per hectare sampled in 2018. However, if we compare the average of previous years, this comes to 59,5 tonnes per hectare. If we include the year 2018, the average good is 50 tons.

Numbers truthful?
The result of VTA is very likely in the upper regions of the Netherlands. As with the potatoes, the picture may be clouded by the location of the samples. The members of VTA traditionally live on the clay soils in the southwest and in Flevoland. There is more precipitation here and a lot of rain compared to the east of our country.

VTA also notes that the spread per plot is very large. The lowest sample is below 25 tons per hectare and the highest at almost 85 tons. Whether it could be irrigated makes a lot of difference. In the central and northern Netherlands, the average yield is 62,4 tonnes per hectare. The south is at 51,5 tons per hectare.

Size average
In terms of size percentage, the onions are also average. The percentage of 60 millimeters upwards is at 57%, which is equal to the average. In the south of the country, onions are slightly coarser on average. This means that the onions of 2019 are not overly coarse. In 2015, a percentage of 62% was achieved.

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Niels van der Boom

Niels van der Boom is a senior market specialist for arable crops at DCA Market Intelligence. He mainly makes analyses and market updates about the potato market. In columns he shares his sharp view on the arable sector and technology.
Comments
11 comments
Subscriber
leo 17 September 2019
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness[/url]
59,6 tons compared to 41,4 tons is an increase of 43%. Since when is this called doubling?
The lion 17 September 2019
Almost doubled, but counted well. Let the price drop VTA!
Subscriber
Niels van der Boom 17 September 2019
leo wrote:
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness[/url]
59,6 tons compared to 41,4 tons is an increase of 43%. Since when is this called doubling?
Dear Leo,

A (almost) doubling refers to the total harvest. Hectare yield of 59,6 tons/ha x 27.800 ha of seed onions = 1.656.880 kilos of onions. In 2018, the harvest amounted to 887.648 tons.
JM 17 September 2019
And just publish numbers. Trade sucks.
What does VTA intend to achieve with the publication of this data, a better grower price?
I expect a counterproductive effect.
I do know one thing, I see a different picture in my environment than VTA paints.
Subscriber
Farmer Jan 17 September 2019
Niels vanderboom wrote:
leo wrote:
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness[/url]
59,6 tons compared to 41,4 tons is an increase of 43%. Since when is this called doubling?
Dear Leo,

A (almost) doubling refers to the total harvest. Hectare yield of 59,6 tons/ha x 27.800 ha of seed onions = 1.656.880 kilos of onions. In 2018, the harvest amounted to 887.648 tons.
Some simple journalism here,
The report from the VTA states that the average yield of trial grubbing is on irrigated plots and in areas that have had reasonable water.
Simply extrapolating and multiplying figures never gives a realistic picture and disrupts the market, this cannot be the intention of both VTA and BB.
The same message contains a total harvest forecast corresponding to 5 average years, excluding 2018.
The headline of the press release reads: Yield onions approximately at long-term average.
Vta indicates to expect a total harvest of 1.2 MJ tons of onions, 400.000 tons difference, with the article mentioned above.
By the way, export is booming, for good bale prices, plenty of opportunities for traders and exporters. Don't let misreporting spoil the opportunities for farmers.
Groningen 17 September 2019
my clog breaks completely. first spoil the potato mood and now the onions. Goodbye VTA!!
Subscriber
peter 17 September 2019
Farmer Jan wrote:
Niels vanderboom wrote:
leo wrote:
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness[/url]
59,6 tons compared to 41,4 tons is an increase of 43%. Since when is this called doubling?
Dear Leo,

A (almost) doubling refers to the total harvest. Hectare yield of 59,6 tons/ha x 27.800 ha of seed onions = 1.656.880 kilos of onions. In 2018, the harvest amounted to 887.648 tons.
Some simple journalism here,
The report from the VTA states that the average yield of trial grubbing is on irrigated plots and in areas that have had reasonable water.
Simply extrapolating and multiplying figures never gives a realistic picture and disrupts the market, this cannot be the intention of both VTA and BB.
The same message contains a total harvest forecast corresponding to 5 average years, excluding 2018.
The headline of the press release reads: Yield onions approximately at long-term average.
Vta indicates to expect a total harvest of 1.2 MJ tons of onions, 400.000 tons difference, with the article mentioned above.
By the way, export is booming, for good bale prices, plenty of opportunities for traders and exporters. Don't let misreporting spoil the opportunities for farmers.
Yes, there is no point in publishing these figures, rather think that the 15% of drying in headlands and spray trails will still have to be removed and then it is still high. You will never get a good average because it depends entirely on how many participants from contribute to a specific area.
Subscriber
pieter 17 September 2019
peter wrote:
Farmer Jan wrote:
Niels vanderboom wrote:
leo wrote:
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness[/url]
59,6 tons compared to 41,4 tons is an increase of 43%. Since when is this called doubling?
Dear Leo,

A (almost) doubling refers to the total harvest. Hectare yield of 59,6 tons/ha x 27.800 ha of seed onions = 1.656.880 kilos of onions. In 2018, the harvest amounted to 887.648 tons.
Some simple journalism here,
The report from the VTA states that the average yield of trial grubbing is on irrigated plots and in areas that have had reasonable water.
Simply extrapolating and multiplying figures never gives a realistic picture and disrupts the market, this cannot be the intention of both VTA and BB.
The same message contains a total harvest forecast corresponding to 5 average years, excluding 2018.
The headline of the press release reads: Yield onions approximately at long-term average.
Vta indicates to expect a total harvest of 1.2 MJ tons of onions, 400.000 tons difference, with the article mentioned above.
By the way, export is booming, for good bale prices, plenty of opportunities for traders and exporters. Don't let misreporting spoil the opportunities for farmers.
Yes, there is no point in publishing these figures, rather think that the 15% of drying in headlands and spray trails will still have to be removed and then it is still high. You will never get a good average because it depends entirely on how many participants from contribute to a specific area.
VTA has 750 members on ????????onion growers think 20% share
of those 20%, 20% actually do a test harvesting (assumption) received a message that there was so little information, so you get the results from 4% growers.
Subscriber
Leo 18 September 2019
Niels vanderboom wrote:
leo wrote:
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness[/url]
59,6 tons compared to 41,4 tons is an increase of 43%. Since when is this called doubling?
Dear Leo,

A (almost) doubling refers to the total harvest. Hectare yield of 59,6 tons/ha x 27.800 ha of seed onions = 1.656.880 kilos of onions. In 2018, the harvest amounted to 887.648 tons.
Dear Niels,

You're making a very big stupid fallacy. You are comparing apples to oranges. Let's do the math properly. Last year nationwide 887.648 tons divided by 25.000 ha is 35 tons/ha. Suppose the vta increase of 44% is nationally you arrive at 50 ton/ha.

Then we know for sure that that 44% nationally will never be achieved because in the southwest in the core of the VTA area people have 1000% more yield.

The stated nationwide 1.200.000 tons of VTA in the press release seems to me to be close to the truth.
teacher neat 18 September 2019
Niels, Niels, Niels.........
not good this
Subscriber
Henk 18 September 2019
Everyone is trying to make their point while the trade is laughing its ass off...
You can no longer respond.

Sign up for our newsletter

Sign up and receive the latest news in your inbox every day

News Potatoes

French fries potatoes stop growing in the country

News Potatoes

Question marks about the potential of potato crops

News Potatoes

Underwater weight not extreme in Aviko test harvest

Analysis Potatoes

Potato quality still not guaranteed

Call our customer service +0320(269)528

or mail to support@boerenbusiness.nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Sign up