Also adverse effects

Subsidized windmills make farmers rich

11 December 2017 - Redactie Boerenbusiness - 22 comments

You can't live on the wind, the saying goes. But the 32 farmers in the Wieringermeer, who recently sold their windmills to Nuon, probably think differently. That reports Business Insider.

Financial details have not been disclosed. However, it seems that the deal, which the Wind Collective Wieringermeer concluded with the energy company, made the owners rich in one fell swoop. "Nuon made an offer that we could not refuse," said Jaap van der Beek, chairman of the Wind collective.

Keep old mills running for another 5 years

The farmers opted for a lot of money, rather than future profits over a long series of years. Moreover, it is not the collective, but Nuon that is now paying for the necessary replacement of the windmills by larger and more modern ones, costing many tens of millions of euros. After the new wind farm is ready, the farmers are allowed to run their old windmills for another 5 years.

Earning from windmills, with subsidy
"Wind energy is big business in the Netherlands", acknowledges Axel Posthumus, director of the cooperative Windunie, advocate and advisor to about 250 wind turbine owners. According to Posthumus, the deal with Nuon illustrates how profitable wind energy can be for enterprising farmers.

That is not new. At the end of the 90s, arable farmers, livestock farmers and horticulturists in Flevoland, North Holland and Friesland in particular already discovered that windmills can pay off. Although the cost price of the electricity generated by their turbines significantly exceeded the market price for electricity, that loss was amply compensated by the government, which generously sprinkled subsidies.

This is no different in 2017. The government is investing heavily in 'renewable electricity'. The subsidy scheme from the end of the last century has since been replaced by the Stimulation of Sustainable Energy Production, called SDE+. In 2017 and 2018, approximately €12 billion is available each time. Many millions from that pot will go to windmill projects on the mainland. The period for which a project approved by the government can count on a subsidy has also been extended to 15 years.

Government offers stability
Whether SDE+ is attractive? Yes, according to Posthumus: "Entrepreneurs know where they stand. There is stability in the subsidy policy." When determining the subsidy, the market price of electricity is discounted (deducted from the subsidy). With a high market price for electricity, the subsidy goes to 0. But with a low price, the windmill owner is assured of a certain price and a return of about 7% to 10%.

These are hefty sums

Farmers are catching on to this, because it involves substantial amounts. A calculation example on the website of the Netherlands Enterprise Agency shows that a windmill costing more than €4 million with a capacity of 3 Megawatt, based on the subsidy scheme of 2017, can generate around €450.000 in turnover (of which €300.000 is a subsidy) per year. to generate.

Build a windmill soon, then? "It's not that easy. There's a lot to consider," says Posthumus. "The rules are very strict. Projects require a long preparation time. In that phase you have to bear the costs yourself."

In addition, government policy today is strongly focused on the construction of streamlined parks of 10, 20 or even more windmills with blades that reach a height of 200 meters or more. Such turbines provide much more power than the current, independently installed windmills of individual farmers, which often stand criss-cross in the landscape.

The interests of farmers are different from those of local residents
The increase in scale and high investments force land owners to cooperate. That is why farmers unite in a cooperative or BV. However, conflicts of interest are always lurking. After all, from a commercial point of view, every owner wants as many turbines as possible on his own plot.

Entrepreneurs often agree, practice shows. Most windmill projects fail or do not get off the ground for some other reason, according to Posthumus: "Lack of support among local residents." The complaints are legion. Such as horizon pollution, cast shadow of the blades, reflection of sunlight, permanent buzzing sound, depreciation of the house.

Plans for a wind farm can split a local community. In 2009 a select group of farmers in the Drenthe Veenkoloniën attacked the inhabitants of various villages with advanced plans for a large and lucrative wind farm. The locations of the windmills were already determined. There was no prior consultation with local residents. The entire project had already been discussed with Rijk.

The project is at a deep stalemate

The consequences were, to say the least, nasty. Former best friends got into a fight, neighbors stopped talking to each other, church communities fell apart and opponents sabotaged the maize harvest of one of the 'grabbers'. The project is at a deep stalemate. It is doubtful whether windmills will ever be built in the Veenkoloniën.

The lesson? "Initiators for wind farms would do well to consult with citizens at the earliest possible stage, in order to search for the best location together," advises Axel Posthumus.

Which also helps to gain support: local residents, or even the entire local community, to share in the expected profit of the park. Money can be the lubricant that keeps windmills running smoothly.

Read more on Business Insider:
This Hague city greenhouse plus fish farm from UrbanFarmers must reintegrate the farm into the city

The Westland grower who made Tommies' children's tomatoes a European success, also wants to get millennials into the vegetable snack

5 Reasons Bitcoin Is Going to Crash – And 2 Charts Showing What Might Happen Next

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know
Comments
22 comments
IJsselmeer clay 12 December 2017
This is a response to this article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness.nl// artikel/10876863/subsidized-windmills-maken-boeren-rijk][/url]
That last paragraph has a very high SP content. It's great that the farmer takes a financial risk with the construction of a windmill, but if money can be earned then Henk and Ingrid would also like to catch some. Do they also contribute if the windmill unexpectedly loses money, because there are also countless stories and if I am not mistaken there are even articles about it on this site.
Subscriber
Out of the way 12 December 2017
OOOOh now it's a high SP level. Everyone knows that having a windmill is simply a matter of walking in because of the subsidy.

It is arbitrary and fortunate that a windmill is allowed to stand on your land.

There's no risk at all, it's just grabbing, grabbing and grabbing some more.

And indeed, as soon as a farmer has a windmill, he is finished with SP because then sharing is suddenly no longer possible
Subscriber
agricult 12 December 2017
risk is zero. especially in North Holland, always wind. Two thirds of the proceeds are subsidies, so there is absolutely no entrepreneurial spirit.
IJsselmeer clay 12 December 2017
@On the side] When those solitary windmills were built in the 90s, that yield was not yet so fixed for a longer period, that it turned out this way is in favor of the entrepreneurs and not of the environment? This article is about those entrepreneurs, that due to, among other things, the Wieringermeer wind plan, a complete arbitrariness has arisen in the locations of the windmills and with that the income for agricultural entrepreneurs who happen to have their land in the right location is a completely different discussion.
Subscriber
Bert 12 December 2017
Stop talking about windmills. We have such a terrible plan in Southern Flevoland. Friendships torn, family quarrels/tensions.
It has caused a lot of bad misery.
Why? Greed and egos of a few people who have sat on a board.
Under pressure from provincial administrators and ass licking, mills are being added to farmers who do not want that at all.


Attention : in about 10 years we will say that the decision to build these mills will go down in the black history of our beautiful polder.

There is still a lot of mischief to come.
Subscriber
Berry 12 December 2017
For those who think they will never get a chance or be excluded:

You can all register for a tender for offshore wind from 15 December.

When you have a good business case, you can earn millions with it.

I look forward to hearing from you again.
Subscriber
Dirk 12 December 2017
Best friends,
you should subscribe to the (right-wing) opinion magazine Elsevier.
Several articles have already been written about wind energy. I will not go further into this here. But one thing is certain: windmills run on subsidies and nothing else.
Subscriber
boy 12 December 2017
Bert wrote:
Stop talking about windmills. We have such a terrible plan in Southern Flevoland. Friendships torn, family quarrels/tensions.
It has caused a lot of bad misery.
Why? Greed and egos of a few people who have sat on a board.
Under pressure from provincial administrators and ass licking, mills are being added to farmers who do not want that at all.


Attention : in about 10 years we will say that the decision to build these mills will go down in the black history of our beautiful polder.

There is still a lot of mischief to come.

Id, governance mafia, run only by tenants, self-interest first, manipulation,. and many have signed contracts without knowing what it says. and you can go on and on
Berry 12 December 2017
You are right Dirk. Also on the farm. Each hectare is approximately 350 euros subsidy. The solar panels. 3,3 ct/kwh power output supplemented with approximately 7,7 ct/kwh subsidy. They are opportunities that are offered. Do something with it.
down below 12 December 2017
Bert, what a sickening comment: "Note: in about 10 years we will say that the decision to build these mills will go down in the black history of our beautiful polder."
Are you sure about those things?

I would rather say: "Note: in about 100 years we will say that the decision to build these mills must be included on the World Heritage List, so that our beautiful polder is just as crowded as Kinderdijk is now!"
Subscriber
Dirk 12 December 2017
Friends, wind energy is nothing more than a political goal. waste of money. In addition to the costs of the direct government support to the windmill "farmers" or whatever, there is also a need to maintain capital of installed (electrical) power as a reserve. If you really know what it is you'll laugh to death
But if you have to [and you have to], put that misery in the middle of the sea. Anyway: Not in my backyard!!
7,7ct/kwh subsidy for solar panels have I read somewhere above? Excuse me, I have better things to do.
Einstein 12 December 2017
Dear Bert beautiful polderjQuery21103167161227630143_1513098986807???? With all those crooked lines of windmills that are there now, stop it man.
Hello? 12 December 2017
Einstein wrote:
Dear Bert beautiful polderjQuery21103167161227630143_1513098986807???? With all those crooked lines of windmills that are there now, stop it man.

The only curved line in Zeewolde is the line on the Sternweg, and this may happen to remain standing. The other mills that have to go (+ 200) are everywhere 125m from the center of the road. NBA design by an architectural firm and approved by the municipality of Zeewolde.
texel 12 December 2017
I would like to grab as much subsidy as possible, but no, on one island where the wind is always blowing, no windmills are allowed, only large earthmoving for nature
visionary circle 12 December 2017
Jealousy feeds the frustration and the frustration feeds the jealousy again.
Subscriber
mother superior 12 December 2017
reference was made here to the SP, but the subsidy for this form of energy is raised by all of us, so if it stands out to you, it is allowed if it goes away from you? talk about double standards!
eastern flevo 12 December 2017
here just as barren as in southern Flevoland. a few wind barons who have filled their business with subsidies for the past 20 years and then bought all the land want to do the trick again. now they act as if they are going to let the unhappy of the past 20 years also benefit. but that's all fake. they increase their own earning capacity by 100 % and for the second time empty the subsidy pot and leave some crumbs on a bottom for their unfortunate non-windmill neighbors. here too a deep groove and a great split will take place in the old pioneer community. and id the page in history git and git will be black
boer 13 December 2017
It is not about subsidy because if the electricity price were at a commercial price of 10ct then no subsidy is needed.
The opponents therefore prefer to use up all available fossil reserves in a cheap way first, without taking into account the consequences that this entails or thinking about how to proceed afterwards.
Subscriber
erik 13 December 2017
fortunately, offshore wind is becoming more and more affordable, no parking fees, no nuisance in the area. As long as subsidies are provided for it, wind energy will never become a mature sector
Jan 13 December 2017
@oostelijk flevo If I look at it more or less in E and Z Flevoland, no wind tubes were needed for that. Even without it, life was often not so healthy with live-and-let-live and jealousy.
We even pick them outside O and Z FL. the fruits: often no pleasant 'neighbours'. I'm sorry to have noticed that. Anyway, times and mores have changed elsewhere too, not so much fun anymore, because greed, pride and 'entrepreneurship' strike everywhere. (AZOs we've always had). Will the shore turn the ship before it turns pitch black?
opa 13 December 2017
@jan nice how you describe that. do you remember Jan Terlouw's speech where he referred to the string from the letterbox. In agriculture too, it is all about giving and helping each other in good and bad times. neighbors drive each other off the road for a few hundred euros. that is why all collaborations fail. if they themselves earn 1000 euros extra but the neighbor 1500 then they prefer to let it go. money, greed and disgrace where the windmills are just an example of what brings out the worst in the farming community
Lola 13 December 2017
Farmers? Sometimes they are just people....
Jan 13 December 2017
lola wrote:
Farmers? Sometimes they are just people....

True, but we were used to that differently, weren't we?
That's why it hurts more to have to experience it like this now.
I generally generalize and there are still very good partnerships to be found and the daily dealings are often quite good.
You can no longer respond.

Sign up for our newsletter

Sign up and receive the latest news in your inbox every day

Analysis Energy

Gas price rises due to Norwegian disruption

Analysis Energy

Trade war reverberates across energy markets

Analysis Energy

Gas price at highest level in two years

Analysis Energy

Gas price rises by as much as 13% in one week

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register