Own picture

News Nitrogen

This is how the agricultural sector wants to reduce nitrogen

20 November 2019 - Wouter Baan - 33 comments

The Dutch agricultural sector wants to further reduce nitrogen emissions, but in such a way that there is future prospects for (young) farmers. The Agricultural Collective, a collaboration between interest representatives and farmer protest groups, unanimously presented a plan on Wednesday 20 November in The Hague to tackle the nitrogen crisis.

This plan was presented to Minister Carola Schouten (Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality) and shows the commitment of agriculture to contribute to nitrogen reduction in the Netherlands. Technical measures in particular are suggested as the solution for further reduction, such as using less protein-rich feed, applying manure scrapers, using broader grazing standards and installing air scrubbers.

There must also be a realistic threshold value (of 1 mol per hectare), so that Dutch policy is more in line with other countries within the European Union. "It is impossible to explain why the standards in the Netherlands are stricter than elsewhere", says Aalt Dijkhuizen, the chairman of the Agricultural Collective. 

'Young farmers must be able to continue'
Minister Schouten received the report from Dijkhuizen at a press conference in The Hague. In an initial response, the minister claimed to share the Agricultural Collective's premise. "Getting out of the impasse and continuing to give perspective to the sector. Young farmers must be able to continue." The minister praised the formation of the collective and the speed with which all organizations have started working with the nitrogen plan. "That's great. I'm going to study the report carefully."

In the almost 25 pages The report also states that the Collective wants to lease reduced nitrogen space to other sectors, but does not want to give it up. "Free latent space may not be sold outside the agricultural sector, because this erodes the farmers' stock," says Dijkhuizen. He further emphasizes that the sector does not see itself as the cause of the nitrogen problem. This report therefore provides figures that show that a great deal of ammonia has already been reduced in recent decades: 65%.

Nearly €3 billion needed
With the measures envisaged by the Agricultural Collective, it is possible (in its own words) to reduce in the long term between 7 and 9 kton of ammonia. A reduction of 2020 to 3 kton is achievable by 5. Of course, the plans come with a price tag. The costs must be reimbursed by the government.

The Agricultural Collective estimates the costs for the next 5 years at €2,9 billion, of which €500 million must now be available to implement all plans. "This money must come from outside the budget of the Ministry of Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality. Otherwise, it will be at the expense of other farmers' budgets," says Dijkhuizen. 

10 preconditions
"Sufficient support is crucial to get the farmers' supporters moving," said the chairman. That is why the Agricultural Collective has set ten preconditions. The preconditions vary from no generic contraction to 1 central government policy. The policy must also be based on measurements instead of calculated assumptions made by RIVM. Furthermore, the number Natura2000 areas are under scrutiny.

The Agricultural Collective has previously indicated that it wishes the cabinet to adopt the plan 1-on-1. Farmers Defense Force, one of the initiators of the collective, previously indicated that they would not tolerate cherry-picking from Schouten (in other words: only measures that Schouten would like to take from the plan).

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Wouter Job

Wouter Baan is editor-in-chief of Boerenbusiness. He also focuses on dairy, pig and meat markets. He also follows (business) developments within agribusiness and interviews CEOs and policymakers.
Comments
33 comments
Joep 20 November 2019
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness.nl/ artikel/10884743/zo-wil-de-landbouwsector-stikstof-reduceren]This is how the agricultural sector wants to reduce nitrogen[/url]
If politics does not embrace this, we are one step closer
a revolution unleashed by climate idiots and like-minded nonvaleurs who contribute nothing (except for a lot of noise and excessive media attention).
Innovative farmer 20 November 2019
I don't think air washers are really something to get other parties interested in this plan.
Perhaps natural means, this is much better, also because the air scrubbers do not work properly afterwards and do nothing inside the shed.
The risk of fire is also much greater with air scrubbers
In addition, increasing marketability so that a real warm remediation can follow
Then the person can get out and provide air to the one who wants to continue.
Subscriber
Piet Reitsma 20 November 2019
Why a direct opposition to this press release? Unfounded journalism at its best. Then tell us more about the content of the presented plan. That fits better with this post. Opposition will come.
Subscriber
Editorial office 20 November 2019
Dear Piet, we have placed the 'contrary' to another article, because it was indeed not 'in place' here. We will of course provide more details and comments about the plan as soon as possible. You can also download the full plan by clicking the link in the article above.
Ton Westgeest 20 November 2019
Greenpeace is in a first reaction to wipe the floor with the plans of the Agricultural Collective.

They call the farmers the biggest cause of the nitrogen crisis. I didn't expect anything else.....

Farmers were also the biggest cause of the acid rain, we were also the biggest cause of the hole in the ozone layer, of the phosphate crisis and now the ammonia crisis. It turned out afterwards when the industry had done something about it, eg making soaps phosphate-free, etc. that it no longer applied. That's how it is with everything and now also with nitrogen

You cannot compare these two nitrogens with each other, NOx is poison for your lungs and ammonia is only a fertilizer, which is at most 500 mtr. descends from a farm. With that you fertilize, in most cases your own country.

Industry, traffic, aviation and shipping will have to work again to tackle the real problem, just like with phosphate. Otherwise this will not be solved.....

I think that the green lobby, including Greenpeace, Natuurmonumenten, Milieudefensie, Dierenbescherming and others, are part of the problem themselves. They are working on structurally creating and expanding nature parks. Parks that do not deserve the status of nature, but with which a lot of money is raked in. As a result, lock the Netherlands with the rules.

If the politicians want to go that way, let them just say it honestly.... We certainly don't have a manufacturing industry anymore, and we also want the food to come from abroad...

But don't say when things go wrong: "I can't remember!!!!"
According to the 20 November 2019
By all assumptions and models, it produces 46% of emissions. Half of the land area is farmland. The agricultural sector is thus not a polluter, but a net "cleaner, cleaner" of a theoretical/political problem. Wake up. Neither the problem nor the solution lies with the agricultural sector.
bull 20 November 2019
Little news in this report, just the language of the actions: we are not the causers, we are not going to shrink, and if we do have to solve it then only with technical measures that are fully paid for by the government, about 2,9, XNUMX billion euros.
With such a report you give the reins completely to the government....
Pippi 20 November 2019
This comment has been removed for violating the forum rules.
Pippi 20 November 2019
The agricultural sector is the biggest cause of nitrogen emissions and now REALLY has to stop being hypocritical!!!!!
OTHERWISE, THE FARMERS WILL INCLUDE A REACTION THAT IS UNKNOWN HWFTIG AND LARGE. YOUR ACTIONS DO NOT INCLUDE ANYTHING!
Pippi 20 November 2019
Of course, other sectors also pollute BUT as far as nitrogen is concerned, the conventional intensive farmers are the largest emitters
So wake up now.
You don't get your way with the weak plans delivered. No good.
Jan10 20 November 2019
This comment has been removed for violating the forum rules
William 11 20 November 2019
is correct Jan10,
pippi has to go to work she knows what she is talking about.
Paul 20 November 2019
Who must go first PIPO, I mean PIPPI
Bart 20 November 2019
@ Pippi.

1. On what do you base the fact that the majority of the Dutch population will not accept this if research shows that approximately 90% of the population supports the farmers? You really need to look beyond your own circle of acquaintances who probably suffer from the same shortsightedness.

2. Do you sometimes accidentally press CAPS LOCK? You are forgiven. Or do you want to give the impression that you are shouting at us? In that case you will have to understand that screaming does not help, or was that not taught to you as a child in Montessori education?

3. Go deep into the subject instead of superficially babbling along with the Jesse's and the Tjeerd's of this world. If you substantiate something, we can talk about it, but just say something (shrink by 50%) and not realize that you don't solve the problem at all makes no sense at all.

4. Regarding the report itself. This contains clear short and long-term solutions substantiated with facts and reductions quantified in Kton. Where there are still uncertainties, it is indicated that research still needs to be done, this only applies to long-term matters where there is also the time to do this. Please indicate where you think the problem is. And then please without yelling and bias!
Dirk 20 November 2019
You can deduce from someone's writing style how someone is in life. Pippi is an unfortunate creature which he makes more than obvious here. You can't argue with someone like that in terms of content, that's symptomatic.
Trudy 20 November 2019
You farmers should be ashamed of yourselves. Should we pay citizens for your filth? Who do you think you are? The king himself, but as a bunch of dictators.
Dirk 20 November 2019
Just stop eating Trudy, you'll hit burps the hardest.
Subscriber
roulade 20 November 2019
This comment has been removed for violating the forum rules
Dirk 20 November 2019
My previous message was meant cynically rollade@. A normal conversation is not possible with veggies, they get angry quickly and often talk gibberish.
Subscriber
roulade 20 November 2019
ok Dirk, clear.
jp 20 November 2019
Trudy wrote:
You farmers should be ashamed of yourselves. Should we pay citizens for your filth? Who do you think you are? The king himself, but as a bunch of dictators.
Trudie, you call "you filth"
I am assuming that you:
-do not eat anything that comes from "us".
- Well, what comes from other countries because that filth (according to you) you are nice and far away from there
- You do not use detergent / cleaning agents, medicines ect ect (talking about filth)
It really is impossible to film how hypocritical some people are.
Oh well, as long as everything is ready for you in the supermarket, it's nice to bleat....
Klaas 20 November 2019
Clear explanation that cannot be limited to dairy farming. And fair that mink farming is involved as far as I'm concerned.
I am skeptical about manure injection, but for the rest I am proud that the collective is doing what it stands for and that it has a voice on behalf of all sectors.
Pippi 21 November 2019
This comment has been removed for violating the forum rules
Subscriber
Editorial office 21 November 2019
As editors, we have removed several comments in this topic, largely due to profanity and person-oriented comments that don't matter at all. Our request to you is to discuss decently with each other. Otherwise we block notorious offenders.

Thank you in advance.
Pippi 21 November 2019
Fine editors take my comments away but realize how many negative derogatory comments are made by other people here. Anti city dweller, anti government, a lot of sexist women and other gender unfriendly language
I wonder what journalists will think and write about this??
I will inform a few more newspaper editors of this. How the farmers here in general behave.
Subscriber
Editorial office 21 November 2019
Dear Pippi, it is very unfortunate that you continue to provoke and threaten and thus apparently do not accept the content of our message (discussing content). The consequence of this may be clear.
Subscriber
roulade 21 November 2019
hey Pippi, I always tell my kids not to use the phone during dinner, work or school.
I understand from this that you do not apply any of them, or that you are only on the telephone/internet all day........... ?
Ton Westgeest 21 November 2019
If the editors don't select on substantive responses, this forum will be over very quickly.
It now seems, completely taken over by self-righteous, paid activists who have very little understanding, at least of the matter...
tinus 23 November 2019
are you automatically a member of nature monuments when you deliver to friesland?....hope not so
Marie 25 November 2019
We really need to hit heads; through the pain barrier. 40-50% reduction in livestock. Free move the companies to Russia, Africa and South America. Just like with flowers and vegetables .. There is a nitrogen deficiency.
Subscriber
roy 25 November 2019
yes nice help the economy to the moon. there is also no more money for leftist hobbies. do marie and pippi keep their mouth shut? that would be the only advantage.
JJ Gootjes 26 November 2019
Goes well with winter vegetables. Pippis take over. They eat locally grown produce all winter because of the low environmental impact.
The growers in Spain of cauliflower, broccoli and lettuce can stop with Pippis in the Netherlands.
shoemakers 1 26 November 2019
the Pippis have a different mouth of eating than talking!
You can no longer respond.

What are the current quotations?

View and compare prices and rates yourself

News Nitrogen

KDW from law and emission targets instead of nitrogen targets

Opinions Wim Groot Koerkamp

Top-down meets bottom-up in nitrogen impasse

News Manure

Less nitrogen from manure, (still) above new ceiling

Opinions Jaap Major

Agriculture and nitrogen: problem or solution?

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register