Shutterstock

Background Organic

Large-scale switch to organic has risks

13 September 2021 - Jurphaas Lugtenburg - 11 comments

In the plans of the European Commission, organic farming is one of the spearheads to make agriculture greener and more environmentally friendly. A quarter of the European agricultural area must be organic by 2030. However, critics point out that too much of organic farming can jeopardize food security. The situation in Sri Lanka shows that this fear is not entirely unjustified.

The country in Southeast Asia has banned the import of fertilizers and other agrochemical products as of April 29 this year. This makes Sri Lanka the first country in the world to switch completely to organic farming. But in less than six months, that policy has turned out to be disastrous.

Sri Lanka is now in a deep economic crisis. President Gotabaya Rajapaksa even recently announced a state of emergency over food shortages and skyrocketing prices. One of the main causes, in addition to the loss of tourism due to the corona pandemic, is the rigorous switch to organic farming. Daily necessities such as sugar, rice and onions have more than doubled in price due to crop failures and consumers have started hoarding for fear of shortages. 

Lack of knowledge and resources
Research among farmers on the island shows that 85% expect yields to fall sharply due to the ban on fertilizers and crop protection products. Virtually all crops depend to a greater or lesser extent on these products. Only 20% of farmers indicate that they have sufficient knowledge of organic farming practice. Artificial fertilizers could still partly be replaced by organic manure. However, the amount of organic fertilizer available is far too small in relation to the area and the needs of the crops.

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Jurphaas Lugtenburg

He is a market specialist in grains and other agricultural commodities at DCA Market Intelligence. He also focuses on onions, potatoes, and roughage. Jurphaas also runs an arable farm in Voorne-Putten (South Holland).
Comments
11 comments
Subscriber
frog 13 September 2021
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url = https: // www.boerenbusiness.nl/ artikel/10894117/groot-scale-switching-naar-biologisch-weet-risks]Large-scale switching to biological involves risks[/url]
Great, isn't it, war and famine can earn a lot of money for the multinationals.
Flevo farmer 13 September 2021
That's right, the situation from Sri Lanka is seamlessly translated to the EU situation?
DUH 13 September 2021
The world's policy makers are all intelligent individuals with the clear agreement that none of them have common sense or can think logically.
Ruud Hendriks 13 September 2021
What Sri Lanka has done is not to switch, but to ban fertilizers and pesticides nationwide. That calls for trouble. Organic farming is not about what you leave out, but about what you do do. To compare this with the European situation? Comparing apples and pears is even easier.....
Subscriber
frog 13 September 2021
ruud hendriks wrote:
What Sri Lanka has done is not to switch, but to ban fertilizers and pesticides nationwide. That calls for trouble. Organic farming is not about what you leave out, but about what you do do. To compare this with the European situation? Comparing apples and pears is even easier.....
Otherwise, I think it's a great challenge to really grow Ruud organically without protecting your neighbor who does spray and thus keeps the disease pressure low.
gerard 13 September 2021
part of the Netherlands is able and willing to pay the additional cost
the rest talk about it but don't do it because the mobile phone and or car or vacation is much more important than food, which is enough
Flevo farmer 13 September 2021
gerard wrote:
part of the Netherlands is able and willing to pay the additional cost
the rest talk about it but don't do it because the mobile phone and or car or vacation is much more important than food, which is enough
The price is that low, as long as there are still farmers who offer it for that money.

Only the farmers can never unite, because there is always 1 who does it for less.
Subscriber
Narcos 13 September 2021
ruud hendriks wrote:
What Sri Lanka has done is not to switch, but to ban fertilizers and pesticides nationwide. That calls for trouble. Organic farming is not about what you leave out, but about what you do do. To compare this with the European situation? Comparing apples and pears is even easier.....
The same is true in Switzerland, hardly any harvest due to potato blight. But these can simply import what they guzzle themselves, which is nice if half of the EU has to go organic. Begging staff Carpenter French.
John Kerkhofs 14 September 2021
They should have taught the farmers and horticulturists in Sri Lanka how to work organically. Now nobody knows how to act and they work without artificial knives or pesticides and that hinders the growth of the products, there is no or insufficient humus/organic fertilizer to work the fields. They were faced with a tolerated fact from one day to the next, which has resulted in many demonstrations and more, but the government is doing what the current sponsors want, because if they don't, this money tap will be turned off.
Long live democracy.
Subscriber
Drent 14 September 2021
Oh well, that's the same here, the organic farmers do supply digistate that comes from vegetable fermenters, otherwise nothing will grow. It is conveniently forgotten that this comes from conventional agriculture.
Subscriber
Erik 21 September 2021
Forcing the market to 25% is completely wrong. Let the market ask those who want to buy it. Let the growth be voluntary and slow, not forced and fast. (organic always grows slower and according to nature than regular)
You can no longer respond.

What are the current quotations?

View and compare prices and rates yourself

News Organic

HAK significantly scales back its organic ambitions

News Enterprise

Millions in subsidies to stimulate organic sales

Call our customer service +0320(269)528

or mail to support@boerenbusiness.nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Sign up