Shutterstock

Background Nitrogen Mood

Table guests wanted for Adema's feast

18 May 2023 - Klaas van der Horst - 15 comments

The hunt for one coalition of the willing, of organizations and people who want to sign LNV Minister Piet Adema's fervently desired Agricultural Agreement, has started to show desperate traits in the last week. Even staying overnight until Ascension Day did not yield an agreement this morning (Thursday). After all other farmers' organizations, LTO Nederland and NAJK are also in danger of dropping out. And without LTO, the agreement makes no sense, Adema also notes. In our Nitrogen Mood section, we give an impression of the nitrogen crisis in our own way.

The persistent search for participants for the drawing session, continuing until the first light of morning, evokes almost biblical images. Possibly it also passed through Adema's mind, the one parallel to inviting guests to the King's banquet. One after the other apologizes because they have better things to do. Finally, the homeless and vagrants are brought in.

LTO does not want to go alone
One after the other also opted out of the Agricultural Agreement. With other arguments. Farmers' organizations do not trust the paper they are asked to sign, or think what is asked of them goes too far. LTO chairman Sjaak van der Tak would like to sign on his own, but not with LTO (and NAJK) alone. Yet his willingness goes far. Last week he helped Adema firmly to convince agricultural sector organizations and, if necessary, individual companies.

Shake app
He motivates his efforts in an app message to fellow drivers. In the hunt for co-signatories, even individual (large) farmers would have been approached. Whether the loot from this raid will be big enough remains to be seen. Few parties provide a real feast, rather a meal with the necessary acid, which they have to eat with long teeth. Adema moved the deadline on Tuesday - an agreement is also allowed after Ascension Day and indicated that it might also be able to live with a partial agreement. Anything for something that can be called a result.

Grumbling in ZLTO circle
Still, the question is whether - even if LTO and NAJK do sign - there will be a final agreement. It is also starting to rumble within LTO. In the ZLTO area, a group of dairy farmers is on the edge of their seats to jump on that moment. What worries them in particular is the grassland standard desired by Adema. According to the farmers, this looks suspiciously like the plan for 65% protein from their own land, which LTO and NZO launched in 2018. There was a lot of opposition to this, which led to the ZLTO calculating the consequences.

Income effect
For a large proportion of dairy farmers in Brabant, this would have disastrous income effects, with losses of around 60%. Current calculations by feed companies show that the grassland standard will have a comparable effect. The compliance of farmers (not necessarily their organisations) is also not increased by the fact that new examples keep popping up from other sectors, where seemingly anything is possible.

Recreation out of the picture
While the rules for agriculture are being tightened more and more and Minister for Nature and Nitrogen, Christianne van der Wal, is releasing hundreds of millions for the purchase of farms close to nature, the recreation sector is not being hindered much. This week it came out that the nitrogen rules have not been taken into account for a large recreation park near Elburg. According to Statistics Netherlands, the Netherlands will have roughly 2021 holiday homes in 124.000, not including mobile homes. Their number is also increasing rapidly. Many of these shelters are close to or in vulnerable nature, but there is little supervision. Statistics Netherlands reports that there is no proper registration of how many people stay there, who they are and also what the activities there mean for the environment. And are busy recreational activities, such as mountain biking, allowed in or close to vulnerable nature, while farmers have to leave? 

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Klaas van der Horst

Klaas van der Horst is a passionate follower of the dairy market and everything related to it. He searches for the news and interprets the developments.
Comments
15 comments
Subscriber
Zeeuw 18 May 2023
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url = https: // www.boerenbusiness.nl/artikel/10904262/tafelgasten-wanted-for-adema-rsquo-s-feestmaal]Table guests wanted for Adema's feast[/url]
If Adema had the authority, an agreement would have been reached long ago. It is still a D66 pattern, no millimeter of space or commitment. There is only one possible response to this: suffocate with the nitrogen government. Come up with an approach that aims for fair distribution and equal monks equal cuts! Even after so much negotiating time, after submitting so much mess to the EU with incorrect samples, only bad samples, even natural bird puddles with high N levels, incorrect stable floor analyzes by CBS of WUR, omitting drought damage in the provincial reports on the state of nature by the renowned engineering firms, their own ecologists ask for alternatives to KDW, even Prof Hordijk now thinks that the Aerius system is no good!, Minister Van der Wal asks her clone in Brussels for strict letters that are lying, innovations are destroyed because there is a chance that their land robbery plan will fall apart, !!?……. Keep up the good work government! They are even more false than MOB and come up with one excuse after another. Stop consultation until the basic requirements are indeed met and until then cancel all regulations about buffer strips and earnings for eco-medals or mirrors
Subscriber
January 18 May 2023
but that's also because our own Sjakie doesn't see it
that man has never been a farmer
don't get it
Subscriber
frog 18 May 2023
Would it really be the case if agriculture worldwide were even cleaner and super sustainable that all problems with our nature, the environment and global warming would be solved?
Subscriber
Louis Pascal deGeer 18 May 2023
I completely agree with Zeeuw and Frog and wonder where the master plan is for the development of the Netherlands in the field of Nature, Public Health and Agriculture in the broad sense of the word, and what could we do to reduce environmental problems? and also by producing healthy food and thus improving public health.
Start with livestock farming What is the real practical value of studbooks are they still necessary and useful? Or should you go for cows that weigh 100 kg less and have the same milk production.
Then you will immediately emit less methane and have lower feed costs. fewer N problems, improved livestock health and easier handling of lighter cows. The flip side is less slaughter weight and you could compensate for that with a kind of subsidy for this type of cattle. Crossing with the Jersey breed seems like a good start to me.
Couldn't you use a different fuel in agricultural machines and tractors, is there enough research into this? Cooperative production and sales are my ideal, because no one is really in charge of their yard anymore. Together you are stronger.
No more green manure, but leave stubble cellulose on the land and let the soil life provide the N it needs. Growing new "catch" crops look at the Bengal hemp (Crotalaria junceae etc.)
"No till", here in Brazil this method is applied to more than 550,000 farms with an enormous reduction in tractor hours per ha per year, less erosion losses, less sensitive to drought, etc. What can we use of this in the Netherlands?
A few questions and suggestions about what we could do,
Subscriber
anna 18 May 2023
"In the hunt for co-signers, even individual (large) farmers would have been approached". And here it goes wrong. Being "big" is a form of power. Big farmers have a big mouth, think they can go their own way. Keep cattle in stables, have priority (especially at banks) with people entering the yard and swear on innovation, which is not a solution. Innovation is a direct cost increase that we cannot earn back in the market. Our products cannot be sold a penny more expensive!
Subscriber
Louis Pascal deGeer 18 May 2023
Well, indeed, Anna, being great is a form of power and that is why I think cooperatives are so necessary because they grow because of their members and are often larger than the large individual farmers. Innovation can come from any angle and does not always have to lead to a (temporary) cost increase, but very often there is a cost reduction due to a better approach to the processes. Ultimately, the goal of innovation is to improve processes and that will bring in money, because otherwise even the big ones won't get started. What is really important, I think, is the widespread publicity of successful innovations so that they can be introduced as that money produces by everyone.
Subscriber
jan janssen 18 May 2023
Louis Pascal de Geer, why do you want some form of dependence? Innovation is mainly earned by the people who sell it, except for the farmer! Are you someone who wants to earn from the farmer? The farmers are at the bottom of the ladder. Everything that remains (nothing) is for the agricultural entrepreneur
Subscriber
quite coarse 18 May 2023
Without innovation you stand still and without innovation there is no future.
Subscriber
CM 18 May 2023
The rest of the world comes here to watch the art and is full of wonder how we farm here on the stamps we call farms. But here we invented it; we go back in time to that of Ot and Sien.
Subscriber
Zeeuw 18 May 2023
The alternative tractor is already being tested, electrically and H2, that will be fine!
Asking large companies I find kk weakness of the leader, apparently you are not clear what your basic requirements are. That is necessary now, otherwise no agreement. I'm not going to name them again! I think the industry expects that to be the minimum for the signature and otherwise prefer war! Kapoen in consultation, removing buffer zones, fertilization again as a derogation last year, entrance fee € 250, hours for NVWA official and requesting his visit 14 days in advance….
Concluding regional agreements with nature managers and/or province and/or municipality if it fits in with your business operations. If there is a reminder for NH3, this must be demonstrated through measurements, and after 500 meters that is in any case so low that it gives 0,0 on the meter. For 2olven damage, the hunting license must be operational!
Subscriber
Louis Pascal deGeer 18 May 2023
If you're honest, you quickly come to the conclusion that being independent is just a word in the dictionary, but that in practice no one can really be independent anymore.
In a co-op you are much stronger than on your own, but that's my opinion, ALWAYS wear the hat of the farmers!
Subscriber
frog 19 May 2023
The question is whether a real cooperative still exists, many cooperatives have become large unwieldy companies.
But given the future issues, I think you are right, although I am not at all cooperative.
Subscriber
Louis Pascal deGeer 19 May 2023
Yes, Frog, the question of whether true co-ops still exist is a very topical one, and the danger of them developing into large and unwieldy companies is also an ongoing concern. In the late 70s, during an oil crisis, the Brazilian military regime that was in power at the time decided to adopt and finance on a large scale an advice from the agricultural sector and science on renewable energy from sugar cane.
One of the conditions was that financial aid was only given to companies that would work together in cooperatives. The company I worked for 28 years and I personally have been involved in 5 of these projects from the start. The majority of these cooperatives were formed by landowners/farmers in the State of São Paulo. Almost all of them had no knowledge whatsoever about sugar cane and the process of extracting alcohol from it for fuel.
That meant that the Egos were active at a very low ebb and everything was left to the technical people of the cooperatives who, in addition to building the industry, also took on agricultural responsibilities. At that time, a radius of 30 km from the industry was a guideline to make transport costs bearable. More than 500 projects have been set up, the car industry adapted with alcohol engines and later the flex that can use alcohol and gasoline.
Alcohol was also produced, which can be added in normal spirits up to about 26%. Political pricing almost destroyed the program and became prey for large international sugar companies. A major shortcoming was that no viable alternative for the replacement of diesel oil was found, in addition to a timid start of Biodiesel in which vegetable oils are added. But the positive consequences for farmers and the environment with less air pollution in the big cities are still great.
So much more could have been done, with continued financial support for the cooperatives that would have been able to develop more activities. A lack of vision on all sides!
Subscriber
Jan 19 May 2023
Louis Pascal de Geer, just a little less text!!

Subscriber
gerard 20 May 2023
A coop is a company whose dire members can still remember by name
after that it's just a business
You can no longer respond.

Sign up for our newsletter

Sign up and receive the latest news in your inbox every day

News Nitrogen

KDW from law and emission targets instead of nitrogen targets

Opinions Wim Groot Koerkamp

Top-down meets bottom-up in nitrogen impasse

News Manure

Less nitrogen from manure, (still) above new ceiling

Opinions Jaap Major

Agriculture and nitrogen: problem or solution?

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register