News Phosphate rights

200 dairy farmers bankrupt, who's next?

June 13, 2018 - Herma van den Pol - 35 comments

About 200 dairy farmers are technically bankrupt and another 150 will follow almost immediately. In total, approximately 800 dairy farmers have their backs against the wall, which amounts to slightly more than 4% of Dutch dairy farming. There is a fire letter and a petition can be signed, but if necessary Innovative comes out of the Knel with more actions.

About 800 dairy farmers are in a pinch, but according to the rules they are not a bottleneck. Henk Antonissen, who represents the dairy farmers, states that they were close to a solution a while back. However, hours of work were wiped out in 5 minutes. Carola Schouten, Minister of Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality (LNV), indicated that she could do nothing and once again called on the banks to help.

Victims
Behind the scenes, the tensions surrounding the new regulations and the long-term lack of clarity have already resulted in victims. The impact of Schouten's decision not to help is therefore significant. "The dairy farmers are very resilient and go back to work every day. In order to continue, all financial resources (that can be used) are used to keep their breath," says Antonissen. 

You must be able to build on permits

However, the foreman also sees that there is much that the outside world does not know and there they try with a burn letter en petition to bring about change. A letter signed by Hennie Verhoeven, a policy-oriented environmental expert, among others. She motivates her support on Twitter as follows: "If permits are issued, entrepreneurs must be able to build on them. That applies to this group, but in fact to all entrepreneurs! We should not just find breaking companies so easily in the Netherlands."

Fine ahead
About 800% of the 25 dairy farms appear to be technically bankrupt. "These are companies that have 100 cows too much on the basis of the phosphate rights, for example. They need the milk money to pay the bills, but at the same time know that a fine will follow next year. That is an economic offense and the fines are quite substantial. ." It basically means that when the cows leave, the bills can no longer be paid and the companies have to close their doors.  

"After these companies, another 150 companies will probably follow. Those companies now have to have the accountant calculate the actual state of affairs. Sometimes it can still look reasonably good on the current account, but when things are calculated the situation turns out to be very different."

Time is running out
Time is now running out for dairy farmers, who have actually been checkmate since 2 July 2015. It involves large amounts, but for many livestock farmers the emotional value is even greater. Until now, the government has indicated that it cannot do anything, yet the livestock farmers are not giving up. 

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Herman van den Pol

Herma van den Pol has been with us since 2011 Boerenbusiness and has developed over the years into a market expert Milk & Feed. In addition, she can be seen weekly in the market flash about the dairy market.
Comments
35 comments
Gerard June 13, 2018
This is a response to this article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness.nl/melk-feed/ artikel/10878872/200-melkveehouders-failliet-wie-volgt][/url]
don't get crazier understand the hard working livestock farmers
Joop June 13, 2018
Terrible stories like this but it will remain the case if these 800 cases were helped, the rest of the sector would have to bleed and that would be too crazy for words
It remains a business risk that is taken in almost all cases with the approval of the banks. It is now the turn of the banks, but they are hiding behind their policy. Minister Schouten must put much more pressure on the banks.
Do you June 13, 2018
That is exactly what it is about, we have enough land, all but all permits received, father became ill, the stable did not come, it is simply said but you let a citizen buy a house with inescapable obligations involved and say 2 weeks before delivery that he may only occupy half of it, well I can tell you that the Netherlands is upside down. If this continues, we and many farmers will go with us to the Gallemes.
dth June 13, 2018
It's all about
34 c nobody can do it, for company towards future!!!!!!
they count on it in plans, but they are way above it.
Bob June 13, 2018
Dijksma already said in November 2014 that dairy farmers were running into the phosphate ceiling, so it cannot be the case that other dairy farmers who have (almost) not grown will be charged for this.
Here too there are young dairy farmers who want to move on.
I believe that many dairy farmers have gambled on a bottleneck arrangement just like they did in the quota era and are now disappointed.
I would say, let the government partially compensate this group of farmers, they also have new buildings in return, because in fact they have done nothing wrong and then the rest does not have to pay for it!!!!
Gerrit June 13, 2018
These companies should not whine. These thought they were just as smart by growing considerably. Now they get the member on the nose. I therefore believe that the minister should stand firm, rules are rules, and that applies to everyone, including those 800 companies.
Joop June 13, 2018
The Rabo should think about who they are and what made them big. They can also spend the sponsor money for a year on this group of cattle farmers, they are certainly out of trouble and the Rabo cultivates some goodwill with the farmers (do they need it) ).
erik June 13, 2018
If they sell 5-10 hectares of land and buy phosphate rights for it, the stable can be full and the bills can continue to be paid.
Karel June 13, 2018
I think there are more abn amro customers in trouble, because it couldn't go crazy enough there.
Ground from under your company and the rest is worth nothing.
The same with phosphate rights that should not be financed, after all, it is all air. If I was a quitting dairy farmer I would quickly sell the rights. You must be crazy if you pay more than €200 / kg phosphate.
Subscriber
dth June 13, 2018
Precisely Gerrit, those companies thought they were smart, and a big mouth blah blah.
Now also talk quietly and solve it yourself, instead of walking endlessly whining
Hans June 13, 2018
The government could pay damages for hardships,
So that shouldn't come from the other farmers.
They have already been cut into cows.
Kyra June 13, 2018
No, not only the so-called bottlenecks that have bundled themselves are in trouble because of everything. What do you think of companies with livestock that they don't get by name? And when will we see where we need to go. This takes too long
piet June 13, 2018
Don't bullshit Gerrit!! What are rule? Today this, tomorrow that? Everyone complied with the then laws and regulations. Nice and easy, yes, to exclude a group afterwards if it turns out that people at the "rudder" are no good. They don't farm people, they need guidance. Making the individual liable as "you should have known" is too crazy for words. The proposals that IUDK makes do not harm the other farmers
Gerrit June 13, 2018
Piet, are you one of those 800. Now they are whining about things they have done to themselves. You could have foreseen this measure in advance. That Agnes too (farmer looking for a wife), his own fault, big bump. I have no pity.
Luckily I'm not the only one who thinks this way.
Roel June 13, 2018
Gerrit, why so frustrated? What are you afraid of
jpk June 13, 2018
The sector is being smoked out under the leadership of Mrs. Schouten and Mr. de Groot of D66. Look at Belgium. Get compensation for fox damage. The Belgians are careful with the agricultural sector in Ned, which is only important for tourism and in kind 2000.
Gerrit June 13, 2018
Roel, I'm not frustrated or scared. As a retired dairy farmer, I view these measures soberly. Without expansion, we also brought cows to slaughter. That hurts, but unfortunately. The rules are now the same. The son who took over the company has the same thought in this.
Subscriber
Nico June 13, 2018
If you as an entrepreneur are blind to risks, you will now have to sit on the blisters. Gambled and lost. If you did not want to see those signals because you were in a tube vision after the abolition of the milk quota, you should not now say that it is the fault of others that they piss next to the pot. Farmers who have not grown or who have acted risk-consciously have had them surrender that is unjust in my opinion.
Johan June 13, 2018
Gerrit, behave normally! In this way you are not an example for your own son. I also don't think you have the opportunity to look "in the kitchen" with your own son. The world is different behind the scenes
Subscriber
Skirt June 13, 2018
Joop wrote:
The Rabo should think about who they are and what made them big. They can also spend the sponsor money for a year on this group of cattle farmers, they are certainly out of trouble and the Rabo cultivates some goodwill with the farmers (do they need it) ).


Don't understand what you're talking about, banks used to pull the plug on loss-making companies too.
Are you saying that a bank has to pump dry a sinking ship? Then you are a strange world, just remediate the bad companies asap, then there will be room for the rest that can continue, zombie companies are of no use to anyone.
milker for nothing June 13, 2018
Maybe they can cut back the cool colleagues who quickly built a stable with foreknowledge and who have received phosphate rights to help the real problems with that.
Huug June 13, 2018
Schouten just has to buy rights for problems then nobody has to hand in there is enough money look at southern Europe
Dirk June 14, 2018
Dear people, there is nothing new under the sun 34 years ago, the same happened to me and many with me when the milk quota was introduced, just finished the stable 20% extra heifers, and then we were immediately cut 20% quota, we received no support from anyone, then the landlord called, that I should not think that the milk quota belonged to me, but from him if I did not make it, he could not give anything for my stable and at least half of the quota was his abuse us again, as a result of our unbridled urge to be farmers.
Peters June 14, 2018
An entrepreneur buys money from the bank, feed from the feed farmer, etc. Don't start talking afterwards, you were there yourself and thought such a large stable was very cool. You are an entrepreneur or not (hobbyist).
Farmer Henk June 14, 2018
The banks must extend the depreciation period for phosphate from 5 to 25 years, then it will become cheaper per cow per year to purchase phosphate.
tinus June 14, 2018
just sell some land and buy back rights problem solved....
Subscriber
dth June 14, 2018
Farmer Henk wrote:
The banks must extend the depreciation period for phosphate from 5 to 25 years, then it will become cheaper per cow per year to purchase phosphate.



Come on, sacrifice half your working life to earn back some rights, no super from the banks to set it tight at 5 years, and keep it!
Huug June 14, 2018
For nothing Melker, brilliant idea
realist June 14, 2018
if you let it get to the point where environmental lobbyists in the western hemisphere can play the masses, eventually society will be run by a bunch of morons
Huug June 14, 2018
For nothing Melker, brilliant idea!
Kiwi June 14, 2018
Who is actually responsible for his own company .....decisions .....loansThe bank. The Government YOU YOURSELF And no one else......
shoemakers1 June 15, 2018
who can still decide on their own company?

who should bear the risk of the decisions?
Subscriber
Dirk June 15, 2018
Dirk's response on 13-06-18 07.33 is not mine. That Dirk is not an insider
shoemakers1 June 15, 2018
shoemakers1 wrote:
who can still decide on their own company?

who should bear the risk of the decisions?

the official decides today,

the farmer may take the risk
Subscriber
Jan June 15, 2018
Kiwi wrote:
Who is actually responsible for his own company .....decisions .....loansThe bank. The Government YOU YOURSELF And no one else......


Unfortunately, others decide to claim your latent rights.
Unfortunately we don't have a solution anymore, agriculture had the wrong people at the wheel. But yes, also all chosen by themselves.
On to the next round!
Shepherd June 17, 2018
We have 30 empty places in the stable. In fact, it's also a mess. No, getting out of a pinch yourself, that's what you're an entrepreneur for.
You want to grow from 100 to 200? Fine but solve it yourself.
For us, 8,3% discount is also too much.
You can no longer respond.

What are the current milk prices doing?

View and compare it
in the Milk Price Comparison

Call our customer service +0320(269)528

or mail to support@boerenbusiness.nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register