Shutterstock

Background India

Will India also have a milk crisis after onions?

4 January 2020 - Jorine Cosse - 5 comments

Onion prices in India went upside down several times in the past few months. Now the same threatens to happen with milk prices. The Indian government tries to put a stop to this in time, but the milk processors in the country see no point in the solution. 

India, the country with the largest milk supply in the world, has a shortage of milk. Onions are also downright scarce. However, the government did not envision the onion crisis in time. As a result, it was not possible to anticipate the enormous decline in production in time, which caused prices to shoot through the roof.

The onion crisis has made the Indian government wary. To prevent dairy prices from following the skyrocketing onion prices, the government organized a meeting yesterday (January 3). The current state of affairs is being inventoried together with the larger cooperative and private milk processors. The meeting is a response to the prevailing unrest among Indian dairy manufacturers. The manufacturers indicate that the milk supply is considerably lower than in the same period in previous years.

Disappointing flush
Every year India benefits from the so-called 'flush period', the period from October to March. Normally, this period guarantees a higher milk production among Indian dairy farmers, achieved through the availability of better feed and more water.

Normally, this period results in an annual milk surplus. This is then processed into skimmed milk powder and butter by the Indian dairy manufacturers. If shortages occur in the summer, these products are converted back into milk. The flush period, however, is very disappointing this year. This is due to prolonged and unusual rainfall, which causes the fodder crops to grow poorly. 

Due to the lower milk production, dairy prices are rising. Several processors recently increased the consumer milk price by 2 to 3 rupees (= 0,013 euro cents) per litre. This may not seem like much, but by Indian standards it is significant. The prices of skimmed milk powder have even doubled to 300 rupees per kilo (= €3,75).

The milk price is also on the rise, which is of course positive for dairy farmers in the country. The milk with standard values ​​of 3,5% fat and 8,5% protein per liter increased from 19 – 21 rupees (=0,24 – 0,26 euros) to 29 – 31 rupees (=0,36 – 0,39 euros ).

Borders open to import
Due to the milk shortage, the government has decided to open the borders to imports. However, the milk processors are hesitant about this and indicate that this does not work to the advantage of the dairy farmers. They have had a hard time over the last 3 years, because of low milk prices and they are finally recovering.

The idea is that the milk price will deteriorate when the borders are opened. This ensures that the Indian dairy farmer will be hit in his wallet again. The results of the talks between the government and the milk processors are not yet known. 

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Jorine Cosse

Editor at Boerenbusiness who studies the dairy, pig (meat) and feed markets. Jorine analyzes the roughage market on a weekly basis and periodically the compound feed market.
Comments
5 comments
hans 4 January 2020
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness.nl/melk/ artikel/10885195/ get-india-na-uien-ook-een-melkcrisis]Will India also have a milk crisis after onions?[/url]
So things are really being presented 100% wrong here.

It is stated that there is now a milk shortage which results in high milk prices for the farmer.
However, it is only in the last sentence that it becomes clear that the farmers' milk price has now returned to an acceptable level.

Especially for the subsidized milk (products) exporting countries, the expectation is raised that a new "China" is on the way. Once again, hard-working local farmers (competitors in the "global market") can be killed, and western industries will try to capitalize on this opportunity.
Thomas 5 January 2020
The farmer is not allowed to earn anything from the governments and supermarket chains, this has to change because it will burst open, cannot continue due to sustainability
Ton Westgeest 6 January 2020
That's not quite right Thomas, a farmer can earn quite a lot from supermarket chains, it's just that they want to pay as little as possible. Even though there is ten times as much poison in vegetables from abroad. If it costs little!!!

That's called market forces, that's what contemporary politics is all about, you can see that it works in the other direction in healthcare... It is becoming more and more expensive!!

The government also allows you to earn a lot, then they can skim that off with taxes. But in the government there is something completely different, there is a double agenda.... And that also counts double!!
Wim 6 January 2020
8.5% protein?
Thomas 7 January 2020
@Ton Westgeest
That's not right, the government is also very guilty. They let the teachers walk out of the classroom, because they could earn much more in business. In 2009 they themselves put 20% of the care out on the street, and they will never come back. And the supermarkets also only look at short-term profits, sustainability and the farmers help them to death.
You can no longer respond.

What are the current milk prices doing?

View and compare it
in the Milk Price Comparison

News milk

Cono lowers milk price, first for June

News milk

A-ware follows colleagues, but remains in the lead

News milk

Lactalis milk price unchanged for summer

News milk

Arla has kept milk prices stable for 9 months

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register