Shutterstock

News milk

Dairy farmers go to court over MTC

24 September 2022 - Klaas van der Horst - 26 comments

A group of 30 dairy farmers who say they have been duped by the Milk Trading Company (MTC) cooperative has engaged lawyers and are preparing to go to court. The complaint against MTC is deception with dairy futures contracts and violation of financial legislation in Belgium and the Netherlands.

The group has now come out with an official announcement and an appeal to other victims to join. Also the Belgian business newspaper From Tijd paid attention to the affair. The complaint is not only against MTC, but also against DLV/United Experts, which works with the cooperative and facilitates the activities. The group of farmers does not represent all leavers from MTC. At its peak, the cooperative had 330 members. More than 100 of them have now left.
Previously reported Boerenbusiness all that on a turbulent meeting in June painful results over the past year had been announced. It was already known then that about €30 million in investment at MTC had evaporated.

Troubled meeting in June
According to the farmers who now want to go to court, 45% of the members refused to agree to the annual accounts in July, but director Dirk Coucke managed to bend the meeting to his will. MTC continued its course of entering into new forward contracts and incurring losses in practice. The image below of the MTC dashboard clearly shows how the trading was always below the actual market price (see right column). Participating dairy farmers had to keep making additional contributions.

MTCb
The dashboard clearly shows how MTC performed against the market.

The group of dairy farmers who now want to go to court hopes that even more victims will join them. The call contains an email address (dupedemtc@gmail.com)where they can register. Many people who have lost money at MTC feel ashamed. Many farmers are also afraid of MTC driver Coucke, also because he is said to have all kinds of 'tyres' that keep him out of the wind.

Coucke denies
Coucke has always denied that he is doing anything wrong. According to him, the dropouts have weakened their knees and the losses suffered now will be made up for later. The dairy farmers who have left oppose this and argue that Coucke himself does not run any risk with his actions. He does not invest, but receives his earnings by continuing to trade. Coucke fights that in turn. The group of victims is represented by two law firms, including CliffordChance.

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Klaas van der Horst

Klaas van der Horst is a passionate follower of the dairy market and everything related to it. He searches for the news and interprets the developments.
Comments
26 comments
Subscriber
Peters 24 September 2022
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url = https: // www.boerenbusiness.nl/melk/ artikel/10900790/melkveehouders-stappen-naar-rechter-om-mtc]Dairy farmers go to court for MTC[/url]
It is indeed outrageous how DLV and Dirk Coucke do this, Coucke earns more than EUR 400.000 annually, which is why he continues. The other director only receives an expense allowance. I know a farmer who has already had to sell land because of MTC, neighbor is happy with it. There will be more to follow as there is no ceiling built in and it is now hedged for 48 cents.
Subscriber
ex participant 24 September 2022
all financial laws have been broken by dlv
Subscriber
pot loose 24 September 2022
What strikes me is that the role of dlv Netherlands is underexposed. these have very aggressively gained members and made tons of money. put our own staff on the board e still advertise on their own website.

I assume they are also suing this club
Subscriber
dairy farmer 24 September 2022
The chairman of the board has even stopped hedging, no more money. ***** of DLV has also stopped hedging, he says it no longer fits. First sell full and say that you are not at risk, now you don't see it anymore!
Subscriber
prosecutor 24 September 2022
board and initiators jointly and severally liable I think
Subscriber
wishink 24 September 2022
Outrageous way of deception
Subscriber
gaastra 25 September 2022
deeply sad this scam by this man.
Subscriber
of twine 25 September 2022
read the article with great amazement.
Farmers who have to sell their land to survive financially.
Chairman who gets out himself because he can no longer cope financially and dlv who walks away with almost half a million for their advice.

how sad
Subscriber
fellow worker 25 September 2022
If you can finally earn something as a dairy farmer, a dlv will come up with a good plan. ......... ... ....

end of the story, go home with 4 tons, you made no money and lost half your farm
common sense 26 September 2022
we voted for it ourselves
Subscriber
also common sense 26 September 2022
true, but in confidence by dlv
Subscriber
stopper 26 September 2022
Stoppers: email to: duuperdenmtc@gmail.com
Subscriber
Zeeuw 26 September 2022
I think it would be good to elaborate on the contribution of the DLV in this context and to make it known to everyone. With that, the colleagues know how to assess what common sense can do in this matter!
Subscriber
deventer 26 September 2022
they will also come up with a statement or press statement
Subscriber
milks 27 September 2022
spoke this morning to a dairy farmer who was also in it, what a drama. He told that he did not understand anything about it, and how that trade went. Suddenly he had to deposit a lot of money to cover the loss. Now on the IV at the bank.
Subscriber
Sophie 27 September 2022
Looks like t rabo swop debackel only the question now is who is going to pay for it...?
Subscriber
Lawyer 28 September 2022
Sophie wrote:
Looks like t rabo swop debackel only the question now is who is going to pay for it...?
DLV and the board of the MTC
Subscriber
go-getter 29 September 2022
visited Belgium today and talked to a few dairy farmers.

The damage there is much greater than in the Netherlands.
Die Dirck C better emigrate.
common sense 1 October 2022
It could always be worse: this is not a standard but a deception.
We Are the shoulders of our ancestors.

Belgium is not a benchmark, but a death blow in perspective.
(voted vvdnsb? clear, thanks, miscellaneous are turning in the grave..)
Subscriber
grape 3 October 2022
I don't understand your common sense. what do you mean by deception.
not 4 October 2022
grape wrote:
I don't understand your common sense. what do you mean by deception.
does it clearly state or do you want to put him in jail, in our corrupt country
Subscriber
harold cookies 5 October 2022
whoever makes a mistake or breaks the law has to pay
not 5 October 2022
harold koeke wrote:
whoever makes a mistake or breaks the law has to pay
If you don't have the right friends, you have no chance
Subscriber
cover 7 October 2022
Too bad the dlv game turns out to be a scam. I would now like to fix my milk price for a year at 60 plus.

is there no reliable club that can do that
Subscriber
ex participant 23 October 2022
is there any movement among the seniors of dlv?
Subscriber
Southwest 23 October 2022
Everyone who participated walked in with their eyes open, if it seems too good to be true, then it is. If you don't understand, don't get involved guys.
You can no longer respond.

What are the current milk prices doing?

View and compare it
in the Milk Price Comparison

Analysis milk

Milk price at crossroads: another top year or not?

Background milk

Fortunately, German farmer finds support in milk price

News milk

German cooperatives pay the best milk price in the EU

Background milk

Exciting milk price year brings new allowances

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register