Synlait in New Zealand is in dire straits. The profitability of the company, which focuses on the production of high-quality dairy ingredients, is under severe pressure and it is saddled with hefty debts. In addition, the company is at odds with its largest customer, who also has shares in Synlait.
In the past, FrieslandCampina was still a shareholder of Synlait, but the stake of just under 10% was sold in 2017 with a nice book profit of €9 million. At that time, Synlait was one of the fastest growing companies in New Zealand and was called a growth giant in the dairy industry. Currently, the Chinese Bright Dairy is a major shareholder in Synlait with 39% of the shares, but that is more of a burden than a benefit. The company already wrote red figures last financial year and the results are visibly deteriorating.
When the half-year results (which ended last January) were presented at the beginning of this month, it appeared that the loss had increased to $96,22 million New Zealand dollars. Based on a turnover of $632 million, this amounts to a loss margin of no less than 15%, which is excessively high. The loss was also almost five times higher than the expectation that the company shared with the outside world two months ago. Due to the poor results, the stock price took a serious hit. In one year, the price has fallen by more than 200% to 62 cents per share. Recently, at his own request, trading in shares was even halted for a while. Not long after FrieslandCampina sold its stake, the share price was still $13.
Argument with main customer
When announcing the half-year results, CEO Grant Watson spoke almost ironically about challenging times, something that is due to a cocktail of factors. In addition to higher costs and unfavorable exchange rates, the company saw its margins shrink and demand for dairy decline. The company also has to make various write-offs. But that's not the main thing. For example, Synlait has come into conflict with its largest customer, A2 Milk Company. We have been working with them since 2012, especially for the production of infant nutrition. However, A2 Milk Company ended the exclusive production of its product in September last year. In their own words because Synlait allegedly failed to deliver.
It is striking that A2 Milk Company in turn has a 19% interest in Synlait, but that has not prevented the love from cooling off considerably. This is not surprising, because this company also has a majority interest in Mataura Valley Milk, a direct competitor of Synlait, which sees this increasing market opportunities.
Divestment of business units
To turn the tide, Synlait is restructuring. But in the short term, the company is mainly concerned with a mandatory debt repayment. An amount of $130 million should actually have been repaid by the end of March, but that was not possible. Creditors have now granted a postponement until July 15. In total, Synlait is struggling with a debt of $559 million. Management aims to reduce debt and improve financial performance. One of the things being looked at is the divestment of the production facilities on the North Island. Two subsidiaries were also launched last year, but so far without results. Coincidentally, the company indicated this week that it is putting extra haste behind this in order to raise capital.
Synlait is not yet on the verge of collapse. Shareholder Bright Dairy remains confident and has complied with the restructuring plan, as has a consortium of banks. This gives management some breathing space to improve the results, although that does not seem to be an easy task. Although Synlait managed to get out of the red again in 2022 after a difficult period.