Shutterstock

News Manure

OM: 'Less livestock is a solution to manure fraud'

13 November 2018 - Wouter Baan - 17 comments

The Public Prosecution Service (OM) says that the manure problem can only be solved in one way: less livestock. This is what Rob de Rijck, coordinating officer for environmental affairs at the Public Prosecution Service, says in NRC Handelsblad. This is the first time that the agency takes a position publicly.

About 1 year after NRC revealed the large-scale fraud, the newspaper concludes that the problem has not yet been solved. The measures promised by Minister Carola Schouten (Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality) were not (or only partially) implemented.

The newspaper writes that the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority (NVWA) has hardly added any additional supervisors. The code of conduct was only signed by a few dozen companies. Fraudsters can also still apply for a subsidy, while there is almost no is maintained.

In short: the manure problem did not decrease, but increased. However, the NRC does add the nuance that it may be too early to draw up the balance 1 year later.

Financial incentive too great
The Public Prosecution Service endorses the findings of the NRC and says, through De Rijck, that hardly anything has changed in the area of ​​enforcement in the past period. According to De Rijck, only a smaller livestock size can solve the manure fraud.

Only then will the oversupply on the fertilizer market diminish, which he believes is the cause of the problem. On BNR Nieuwsradio, De Rijck said that the financial incentive to circumvent the legislation is currently too great. With less manure, that financial incentive becomes smaller. The Public Prosecution Service has never expressed itself in such solutions before.

clumsy statements 
Schouten is not happy with the statements of the Public Prosecution Service. The timing is unfortunate, because the Netherlands is working in Brussels to extend the derogation to drag in. According to Schouten, the rulings could jeopardize that extension.

Schouten also says that she is working on the size of the livestock via the warm remediation in pig farming. She also says that a new manure system will take at least another 2 years.

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Wouter Job

Wouter Baan is editor-in-chief of Boerenbusiness. He also focuses on dairy, pig and meat markets. He also follows (business) developments within agribusiness and interviews CEOs and policymakers.
Comments
17 comments
DD 13 November 2018
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness.nl/mest/artikel/10880493/om-minder-vee-is-solution-mestfraude]OM: 'Less livestock is a solution to manure fraud'[/url]
Large - scale fraud turned out not to be the case at all . When will this be in NRC. Correction seems appropriate to me.
Gerald 13 November 2018
Yes, and levying less taxes is the solution to tax fraud, building less the solution for construction fraud, less care the solution for healthcare fraud?
??? !!! 13 November 2018
telegraaf: minister about this

She would not say whether the minister agrees with the Public Prosecution Service that the Netherlands would be better off with less livestock and manure. "That is a very political discussion. If I now start with 'we are going to reduce the livestock', I will not get all the parties that I need to get along."

According to Schouten, farmers, livestock farmers, and significant reductions must therefore only be made via LTO: that is as if the new law to be drawn up has already been implemented - pay attention!
john 13 November 2018
compliment to the industry. More inspectors to conclude that manure production is perfectly linked to placement space also seems pointless to me. This gentleman has too often missed the mark when it comes to evidence and therefore makes these statements.

I expect an article from the nrc about how successful it is actually..
Ard Eshuis 13 November 2018
What a bunch of filthy scammers, the whole "manure fraud" was 1 broken card article and see again the hypocrisy in the blocking friezes: They go for the gauze, but Turks and Moroccans don't! What a sick affair it is with the "leaders" of this country!
mores 13 November 2018
What has been said about the nitrate standard in groundwater has been achieved for some time, also on dry sandy soils, according to the recent results of the RVIM
Bob 13 November 2018
Even if there is less cattle, the shit continues
We have a distribution problem!!
Turning off the gas tap to the fertilizer factory will increase the demand for manure!
xx 13 November 2018
Gerald is absolutely right. We can also lower the speed limit on highways further and further as long as people are still driving too fast. We will soon be below 80.
These are just useless comments.
Dorus 13 November 2018
In my opinion, Geert Wilders also said something like this after the elections and is being taken to court, How is it possible that we as an agricultural sector allow everything to come over us. And then from the Public Prosecution Service,
Bert 13 November 2018
journalism must be punishable for spreading lies.
Padre 13 November 2018
So you see again the independence when it is hard to find . The manure fraudsters are deliberately not tackled because then people can shout at the left-wing lobby that agriculture is no good. In this way, the case of Schiphol and other airports where fraud is committed with noise and CO2 and other polluting things, cars can be covered up.
The farmer is blamed for everything I hope that a lot of those people have to live in poverty with no luxury and very little food so that they can just stay alive If they can think again how good it used to be
Robert 13 November 2018
@Ard Eshuis

"See again the hypocrisy of the block friezes: They do go for the gauze, but Turks and Moroccans don't!"

What do the 'Turks and Moroccans' have to do with this then?
Dorus 13 November 2018
In my opinion, Geert Wilders also said something like this after the elections and is being taken to court, How is it possible that we as an agricultural sector allow everything to come over us. And then from the Public Prosecution Service,
Subscriber
Jan 13 November 2018
Apparently a third-rate officer of Justice.
What a blunder, to meddle in politics
MA 13 November 2018
Addition to XX:
Not only by lowering the max speed but comparable to less animals is less cars! The chance of accidents is then less.
With fewer cars, you can still drive too fast and with fewer livestock, you can still commit fraud.
If there are no more farm animals, there is even manure. (pets and people) But when there are no more cars, there are no more car accidents.
Karel 13 November 2018
I would like to know how much (artificial) fertilizer is thrown into allotments.
I think way above the norm.
jpk 14 November 2018
Healthy cows have already been slaughtered in accordance with the phosphate law. see CBS figures
You can no longer respond.

View and compare prices and rates yourself

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register