News Jan-Cees Vogelaar

'Cabinet must stop virtual nitrogen game'

20 February 2020 - Eric de Lijster - 13 comments

"This virtual nitrogen game shows the policy of the cabinet. A policy with a lot of ignorance that has sent livestock farming and the country into a crisis. That has to stop," said Jan-Cees Vogelaar, chairman of the Mesdag Dairy Fund, after the presentation of the calculations of the RIVM nitrogen data.

De calculations by the research team Vogelaar gave many new insights on behalf of the Mesdag Dairy Fund, he said. "While I have been working on nitrogen models for 6 to 7 years. The research really shows a completely different picture."

He points out that it is completely unclear how general national nitrogen policy will be developed in the region and on a location-specific basis. "It is a very complex matter. This virtual nitrogen game visualizes the policy of the cabinet. It is all virtual. The effects of this policy are very difficult to calculate. We do not know the results. That is why we must stop it quickly. ."

Parliamentary inquiry
Vogelaar strongly criticizes the cabinet and, in particular, agriculture minister Carola Schouten, who, in his view, has allowed the nitrogen crisis to rise so high because of the actual 'simulation figures' from the calculation models of the RIVM. "This virtual nitrogen game is not the basis for an emergency nitrogen law. So much ignorance has brought farms to the brink and sent the construction industry into a crisis. This cries out for a parliamentary inquiry."

He also criticizes the image that is portrayed in the media of his person and the Mesdag Dairy Fund, which would question the reliability of the research. "Our investigations are sound. We stand for that." He also had a message for D66 and GroenLinks. "If D66 and GroenLinks really care about nature, they should now stop the clamor and whining about halving the livestock. The Agricultural Collective wants to take measures. This year we can further reduce nitrogen by 5 to 8%."

Research with UvA
As previously announced, the Mesdag Dairy Fund will conduct a 3-year study with the University of Amsterdam to actually measure the deposition of nitrogen around livestock farms. This will happen at 2 dairy farms and possibly also a pig farm. RIVM is also participating in this research. "This will be done in great detail, whereby we can also find out the origin of nitrogen. Only when we know all this exactly can we take measures. Now we only row in the dark. In 3 years' time we will know whether the RIVM nitrogen game corresponds. with reality." 

He later adds about the Mesdag research: "We are doing government work here as farmers. The government should have done that itself. Then they would have had the right to speak."

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Eric the Thrush

Eric is a member of the editorial staff of Boerenbusiness. As a descendant of an arable family, farmer's blood flows through Eric's veins. He considers himself a generalist, but with a preference for economics, trends, markets and marketing.
Comments
13 comments
Jb 20 February 2020
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness.nl/mest/ artikel/10885944/kabinet-moet-stop-met-virtuele-stikstofgame]'Cabinet must stop with virtual nitrogen game'[/url]
You can already hear the cabinet fall and flee
peta 20 February 2020
It's good that there are organizations outside of failing LTO that have their eyes and ears open and delve deeper into the problem.
Kudos to the Mesdag Fund, Jan Cees Vogelaar and Geesje Rotgers, who, together with the University of Amsterdam, have really taken the bull by the horns and made it clear to what mismanagement the government, together with the LTO, which is co-poldering, has exposed agriculture.
Politics will undoubtedly be put in order, will that finally happen within the failing LTO?
And further, of course, FDF and Agractie deserve a deep knee bow from LTO, least of all from the farmer's board, after all, it was these organizations that called a halt to this rotten mismanagement that was draining through the polders that brought agriculture in the Netherlands (including LTO members) to the abyss.
AtzeB 20 February 2020
Finally a man with sense!
Ps 20 February 2020
There will be political as well as with a very well-known agricultural organization steakholders And all the old boys and girls in the job network carousell will be accountable, if not with legal consequences and not only in the Netherlands but also the EU with their eco-religion with all those advisors v carpenter's committee
Mark Rutte 20 February 2020
Vogelaar suggests a lot and what he says is not based on facts. Mesdag comes with nothing, they had promised so much; a wax nose or blowing jaws. The fact is that nature sucks; diversity, insects, soil conditions. So generically all nitrogen has to be cut back by 50%; for farmers, industry, cars, etc. Why in God's name is 10% nitrogen added to natural gas?
Subscriber
quite coarse 20 February 2020
Mark, take a ride!!
I don't look at the shitty nature at all.
It grows well, especially in combination with CO2!!!
So gives more plant growth, so more CO2 is captured, more plant growth also means more leaf mass = more evaporation = more cooling.
frits 20 February 2020
too bad that such a hard-won report from the mesdag fund has fallen on deaf ears. Politicians are only concerned with how they can remove agriculture from the Netherlands. Not with solving the real problems in our country.
Marlene 20 February 2020
Nobody is against farmers. But against the pollution caused by smelly expensive food, which leads to unnatural fattening and to extremely high milk production. Inhumane, I say as a farmer's daughter. Fight for a higher price, which I and the entire Randstad and Grachtengordel would be happy to pay
until here and no further 21 February 2020
Open your eyes Marlene, one free trade agreement after another is flying around us, and we only get more demands and higher costs
Subscriber
smart ass 21 February 2020
if the report had been 60% N, all the papers would be full and all the news outlets had left-wing politics in the studio.
Strange that it's not even on the front pages
Subscriber
Crow 21 February 2020
Due to a small price increase, sugar from van gilse is no longer in the super union supermarkets, apparently the canal belt does not like to pay a little more Marlene
farmer 21 February 2020
Funny that the Lto is again so slammed by fellow farmers. They have certainly forgotten that the Mesdag Fund was co-founded by the LTO!!!

It seemed very promising at first, but RIVM has a good response. Unfortunately, it is not a watertight story from the Mesdag Fund....
John Lapwing 21 February 2020
Ned is like a ship out of control this can be solved by sgp fvd vvd cda and pvv to become a political party for the elections of 2021 there will be a left-wing merger of gl pvda pvdd d66 and christian union then there is something to choose
You can no longer respond.

View and compare prices and rates yourself

Opinions Arjan Ausma

Look ahead without losing vision under grids

Background Economy

Extensive livestock farmers receive considerably more than arable farmers

News milk

Other phosphate excretions not coordinated with Brussels

BBTV Lubbert van Dellen

All about renure, nitrogen and new termination scheme

Call our customer service +0320(269)528

or mail to support@boerenbusiness.nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Sign up