Jakob Berg / Shutterstock.com

Opinions Kasper Walter

Does farmers' protest cause green plans to evaporate?

6 February 2024 - Kasper Walet - 9 comments

The farmers' protests that are taking place in our country and neighboring countries this period are not just about nitrogen in our country or the phasing out of subsidies on agricultural diesel in other countries. But especially against the EU's climate and nature policy, which is hitting farmers hard in terms of their livelihoods.

What to think of the nature policy that forces farmers to leave 4% of their arable land fallow or that intensive livestock farming must make way for extensive, unprofitable livestock farming. Intensive livestock farming, for example, is said to play a major role in the decline of biodiversity. Consumers must also consume less meat and dairy. On the other hand, Dutch farmers and their European colleagues also face unfair competition from cheap food from countries such as Ukraine, Argentina and Brazil. Here they do not have to adhere to the same strict climate and nature rules.

Tractors appear, green plans disappear
All this as a result of the European climate and environmental policy introduced by Frans Timmermans in 2020, the so-called 'Green Deal'. Four years later, however, little has come of the sky-high ambitions. Under the motto: 'the leaders appear, so the green plans disappear', all kinds of laws to make the EU greener have been scrapped or weakened. The law to reduce the use of crop protection products has died, a law to make the food chain more sustainable was never introduced, and now at the end of last week the requirement to leave a piece of land fallow for nature management was also suspended.

The fact that European politicians are afraid of the angry farmers has everything to do with the upcoming European elections that will be held in 4 months' time. Right-wing populist parties are gaining ground in the polls and are campaigning against Europe and the green regulatory burden. A message that is eagerly listened to by farmers and many citizens.

A new climate target for 2040
In this situation, the Commission is presenting a new climate target for 2040 this week. A leaked document shows that CO2 emissions from EU countries must be around 2040% lower in 90 than in 1990. This requires an investment of €1.500. billion euros. An astronomical amount of money when you consider that Europe only produces 7% of global emissions. According to the leaked proposal, all sectors must reduce their CO2 emissions. According to the European Commission, the transformation of the agricultural sector is crucial, as is changing consumers' nutritional choices and better reflecting the price of agricultural emissions in the price of the end product. The proposal shows that agriculture is relatively spared compared to other sectors such as energy and transport. CO2 emissions from agriculture must be approximately 2040% lower in 30 than in 2015.

It is very understandable that current EU politicians such as Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission and French President Emmanuel Macron, are afraid of the farmers' protests. All these measures make it virtually impossible for the agricultural sector to earn a good living and they rightly feel that their farm, company and livelihood are in danger of being destroyed. The protests will therefore continue for a while and we will see how strong the backbone of the politicians is.

Kasper Walter

Kasper Walet is a former board member of the agricultural futures market. He has now been working under the name Maycroft for years as an independent adviser on energy and climate to governments and companies from all over the world.

More about

peasant protest
Comments
9 comments
West Flanders 6 February 2024
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url = https: // www.boerenbusiness.nl/column/10907760/late-boerenprotest-green-plans-vaporize]Do farmers' protest let green plans evaporate?[/url]
It's strange that Dutch farmers remain so tame while their European colleagues are allowed to pull the chestnuts out of the fire
Subscriber
time bomb 6 February 2024
I wrote a similar message on this forum, but there were forum members who preferred to stand there and look at it. When I see how neatly our surrounding countries have dealt with this, I think it has sunk in. If not, they will spring into action again, and it will all be a bit grimmer, but still within the norms. Here in the Netherlands there are a few teams that are making a huge mess. Take an example from other countries and don't stand around and watch.
Subscriber
sefO 6 February 2024
Timmermans and his green cloud are a left-wing principle with little or no substantiation.
Realism and more realism is missing from Timmerman's vision.
The agricultural sector knows its mission and works every day to become more and more sustainable, and Timmermans's pushback is absolutely not appropriate for that.
Green Deal is counterproductive, Green Deal is demotivating. Ask yourself why the whole of Europe is on fire, Timmermans asks for the unfeasible, not feasible, not affordable, in short, not realistic at all.
The question is, isn't it punishable to have some kind of law made
by Timmermans, which, for example, the agricultural sector cannot possibly meet. You cannot and should not ask the impossible of farmers.
Subscriber
sea ​​breeze 6 February 2024
Totally agree. Make yourself seen and heard with a top ten breaking points for negotiation, for example substantive discussions at the table. Do not block civilian targets directly, do not cause damage that you then have to pay for yourself. Find the market/squares in your village, give products for free to citizens under the slogan.... Now it is still possible, tomorrow it will be too late…..Franske Timmermans is the eat, eat, eat, eat pirate!
Subscriber
frog 6 February 2024
We can also sit peacefully every day somewhere near The Hague on a highway extension, that is also allowed, but with a BBQ and a case of beer of course, otherwise Esther Ouwehand will also sit there and that cannot be the intention.
Subscriber
gash 6 February 2024
I haven't heard Frans yet, he might be on holiday with his feet in the water in a garden chair on the beach
Subscriber
frog 6 February 2024
Jaap wrote:
I haven't heard Frans yet, he might be on holiday with his feet in the water in a garden chair on the beach
he must be shooting rhinos in Africa
Subscriber
Bio + 6 February 2024
Dear Kasper,
It is assumed that you must be able to calculate reasonably well in your position. But not everyone who can calculate well always does so. "That requires an investment of €1.500 billion. An astronomically large amount of money when you consider that Europe only produces 7% of global emissions." There are roughly 500 million Europeans. So €3000 per person in 15 years = €200 per year. If we arrive at a 90% reduction, that is an astronomically low amount.
Subscriber
time bomb 6 February 2024
I am a huge supporter of protest actions. But dumping rubble and other waste is going a bit too far.
This is where they mess up again. Look at the Belgians. Add a chip shop, etc. This way you can last a long time without having to worry about the police and fellow road users.
You can no longer respond.

What are the current quotations?

View and compare prices and rates yourself

Call our customer service +0320(269)528

or mail to support@boerenbusiness.nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Sign up