Shutterstock

Opinions Chris Poppe

The rural feeling: in which country do we want to live?

24 December 2022 - Krijn J. Poppe - 16 comments

The year is almost over. The top 2000 accompanies the latest work, we are bombarded with lists and annual overviews. Farmer protests and inverted flags will make it to the New Year's Eve conferences. With that in mind, I took 'This is my court' by Chris de Stoop from the bookcase.

Not an economic classic, but a personal story about the parental farm and the decline of farming status. After the self-imposed death of his brother, the Flemish journalist returns head over heels to his native soil to take care of his old mother and the family farm. Eyes open for the star reporter who reported on injustice from all corners of the world: his beloved land of Waas is being squandered, and with it the familiar peasant culture.

Lack of appreciation
Many Dutch farmers must have recognized themselves in the feeling of De Stoop in the past year. Two things particularly bother him. First of all, the lack of appreciation for that beautiful, more than 1000-year-old cultural landscape. The flat land of Flanders, so beautifully sung about by Jacques Brel, is misunderstood. The glorious history fades from memory. Incidentally, De Stoop itself is not very detailed about the centuries of innovation in this area between the major cities of Ghent and Antwerp, around Sint-Niklaas, just across the border at Hulst and the Duchess Hedwige polder, which was flooded this year. The leading agriculture there was based, among other things, on manure imports. There were manure warehouses along the Scheldt that did business with the city councils of Vianen and Rotterdam. Their farmers would also have liked that city manure, but the Flemings offered more, they had excellent sales in the nearby towns.

The second annoyance lies in the relationship between the Antwerp port authority and the nature movement. The latter supports the project developers of the port as long as they are involved in nature development at the same time. In doing so, they send out a signal that they consider the new nature, which for the time being consists of shrubs and nettles, to be more valuable than the nature of farmland birds, hares and pheasants on farmland. That stings De Stoop.

What kind of country do we want to live in
On my list of books that best describe the rural feeling of 2022, Dit is mijn Hof is number 1. The feelings and despair it describes deserve to be taken to 2023. Then our country will get started with a agricultural agreement. You can hope that this will lead to an agreement with society about the role of the countryside between the big cities. About the question of what kind of country we want to live in, about what farming and entrepreneurship means in that regard. With respect and appreciation for history. And farmland without nettles as an opportunity. I have yet to see whether that fundamental orientation is addressed at the negotiators' main table or at side tables with titles like Feed and Manure. Perhaps all those table guests can start the new year with the good intention to reread This is my court and leave it on the bedside table during the negotiations.

I wish you a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.

Krijn J. Poppe

Krijn Poppe worked for almost 40 years as an economist at LEI and Wageningen UR and now holds a number of advisory and management positions. For Boerenbusiness he dives into his bookcase and discusses current developments on the basis of studies that have become classic.
Comments
16 comments
Subscriber
agricult 26 December 2022
This is in response to it Boerenbusiness article:
[url = https: // www.boerenbusiness.nl/column/10902239/het-countryfeel-in-welk-land-want-we-leven]The rural feeling: in which country do we want to live?[/url]
heartfelt, and I hope they read this and absorb it
Subscriber
time bomb 28 December 2022
I have read Chris de Stoop's books. They grab you right in the heart. All from the region where such a beautiful polder is now disappearing under water. This is how farmland/life has been described without any nonsense. Highly recommended for everyone, including van der Wal and her associates. Can tears flow down her jaws again. (she says)
Subscriber
CM 28 December 2022
time bomb wrote:
I have read Chris de Stoop's books. They grab you right in the heart. All from the region where such a beautiful polder is now disappearing under water. This is how farmland/life has been described without any nonsense. Highly recommended for everyone, including van der Wal and her associates. Can tears flow down her jaws again. (she says)
Crocodile tears anyway. Will the first honest politician please stand up!
Claas 1 January 2023
Look up the ship of fools on wikipedia. Then you can read exactly how things have been going for ages.
Not true? @ Krijn Poppe.
Hub Rich 1 January 2023
I once started in "This is my court" but after about one-third I had had it. I read it as one long string of anger at all the negative impacts agriculture and landscape had matched with the blame being 100% outside agriculture and 0% within agriculture. I have no problem with nostalgia. I myself originally come from a mixed farm on South Beveland with meadows with hedges, pollard willows, standard fruit and cattle drinking pools. unfortunately, little or nothing left of it. But often there are many people involved but few to blame. Processes generally go according to their own dynamics. But maybe I stopped reading too soon.
Subscriber
CM 2 January 2023
Huib Rijk wrote:
I once started in "This is my court" but after about one-third I had had it. I read it as one long string of anger at all the negative impacts agriculture and landscape had matched with the blame being 100% outside agriculture and 0% within agriculture. I have no problem with nostalgia. I myself originally come from a mixed farm on South Beveland with meadows with hedges, pollard willows, standard fruit and cattle drinking pools. unfortunately, little or nothing left of it. But often there are many people involved but few to blame. Processes generally go according to their own dynamics. But maybe I stopped reading too soon.
Back in time, that only applies to farmers or what about it. Ot and Sien is history and it should remain that way. We as farmers do not desire poverty and arrears. Those who want it so badly; politicians and urban population, I say: you first and see how long you like it.
Subscriber
time bomb 2 January 2023
Huib Rijk wrote: originally come from a mixed company. Conclusion: These are often the worst, they foul their own nest. Disgusting.
Subscriber
sea ​​breeze 3 January 2023
I don't go along with Poppe's nostalgia.
What I completely miss with Poppe is his knowledge of the matter, or he is really simple, considering how 2 ministers with malicious N data are cheating the whole of the Netherlands for land grabs. What is mala fide about the N numbers: measuring station at Vreedepeel, NH3 max 500 meters from the source, Sea NH3 does not exist, Zeeland agriculture pays 25% for sea ammonia, RiVM knows but is not allowed to correct, LNV knows but does not want to correct, stable floor (measurements) of CBS are performed/calculated improperly, margin of error in NH3 measurements is 35% anyway, Aerius calculation is inaccurate up to 10mol/ha/year and calculations are based on 0,001mol/ha/year. Krijn do something about it and otherwise crawl into your hole and close the door, never let anything be heard from you again.
Subscriber
Hub Rich 3 January 2023
Dear Mr. or Mrs. Time Bomb, the most interesting thing about a judgment is that it says a lot about the person making the judgment. do you think I'm a litter fouler? peculiar. In 1969 my parents were assigned a company in Flevoland. My father was delighted with it. The mixed farm always gave a lot of work with 21 ha divided over 7 plots. Some are reasonably good for arable farming, others are only suitable as grassland: plots with depressions, low-lime clay. I remember when the pollard willows were cut down in the middle of a meadow. Not because my father was against nature or landscape. But simply because they were unimportant subjects. Land consolidation, etc. These were subjects that were completely normal at the time. So also supported by agriculture. I'm not condemning that in any way. Why would I? I had a more than pleasant childhood.
Subscriber
Louis Pascal deGeer 3 January 2023
Yes, I can still see 4 of those D-6 Caterpillars in a row with a plow blade of 1,80 meters that brought up the soil in the Flevopolder. Then, if I remember correctly, farms of 600 ha were set up, which were built on by the government for 3 years to get a reasonably fertile soil, and then the allocation of the farms. Why were we able to think big and collectively during that time? But even then more could have been done with regard to nature's involvement in protecting the plots. Now I believe that a dimension has been added to farmer entrepreneurship and that this is actually moving towards a natural entrepreneurship such as that which is starting to get underway here in Brazil with arable farming and forestry that go together on one farm.
How will we use the land between cities and how can nature reserves be made productive. Questions that must be answered by society. I am in favor of cooperatives and mixed farms, but it is precisely in a cooperative that you can leave everyone to their own devices - arable farmers, pasture farmers, animal keepers who jointly run a mixed farm. I am a great admirer of the nettles that can play a major role, through the products, in healthy business operations. Just ask Warmonderhof in Dronten. Time for reflection and also time for the government to really think, discuss instead of considering the rules from Brussels as sacred!
Subscriber
time bomb 5 January 2023
Mr Rich. A happy childhood doesn't mean you don't have a special way of thinking and acting, and neither does what your parents did. It's about you.
Subscriber
ideas 9 January 2023
What country do we want to live in?
De Groot started his story years ago that the self-sufficiency of agriculture is much too high. That we had to go back so that nature can do better justice. My question now is: Schiphol was necessary as a stopover to refuel in the past. Nowadays the flights are scheduled in such a way that the stopover is there because you can refuel cheaply. If I ever meet De Groot I will ask him why he does not take that with me .
It can freeze or thaw 9 January 2023
idea wrote:
What country do we want to live in?
De Groot started his story years ago that the self-sufficiency of agriculture is much too high. That we had to go back so that nature can do better justice. My question now is: Schiphol was necessary as a stopover to refuel in the past. Nowadays the flights are scheduled in such a way that the stopover is there because you can refuel cheaply. If I ever meet De Groot I will ask him why he does not take that with me .
The most important thing is still not mentioned that the Netherlands and many other areas are overpopulated.




Subscriber
in hiding 9 January 2023
It can freeze or thaw wrote:
idea wrote:
What country do we want to live in?
De Groot started his story years ago that the self-sufficiency of agriculture is much too high. That we had to go back so that nature can do better justice. My question now is: Schiphol was necessary as a stopover to refuel in the past. Nowadays the flights are scheduled in such a way that the stopover is there because you can refuel cheaply. If I ever meet De Groot I will ask him why he does not take that with me .
The most important thing is still not mentioned that the Netherlands and many other areas are overpopulated.




And what do you want to do about it?
Emigrate?
please the solution!!
with the knowledge that the people who have entered here will not leave or cannot leave.
It can freeze or thaw 9 January 2023
in hiding wrote:
It can freeze or thaw wrote:
idea wrote:
What country do we want to live in?
De Groot started his story years ago that the self-sufficiency of agriculture is much too high. That we had to go back so that nature can do better justice. My question now is: Schiphol was necessary as a stopover to refuel in the past. Nowadays the flights are scheduled in such a way that the stopover is there because you can refuel cheaply. If I ever meet De Groot I will ask him why he does not take that with me .
The most important thing is still not mentioned that the Netherlands and many other areas are overpopulated.




And what do you want to do about it?
Emigrate?
please the solution!!
with the knowledge that the people who have entered here will not leave or cannot leave.
In any case, close the borders, this should have happened 20 years earlier in the time of Pim Fortuyn, who already saw the problems we are now in the middle of.

The big cities have already become unlivable shootings and intimidation are the order of the day and will only increase due to the soft policy.




It can freeze or thaw 11 January 2023
It can freeze or thaw wrote:
in hiding wrote:
It can freeze or thaw wrote:
idea wrote:
What country do we want to live in?
De Groot started his story years ago that the self-sufficiency of agriculture is much too high. That we had to go back so that nature can do better justice. My question now is: Schiphol was necessary as a stopover to refuel in the past. Nowadays the flights are scheduled in such a way that the stopover is there because you can refuel cheaply. If I ever meet De Groot I will ask him why he does not take that with me .
The most important thing is still not mentioned that the Netherlands and many other areas are overpopulated.




And what do you want to do about it?
Emigrate?
please the solution!!
with the knowledge that the people who have entered here will not leave or cannot leave.
In any case, close the borders, this should have happened 20 years earlier in the time of Pim Fortuyn, who already saw the problems we are now in the middle of.

The big cities have already become unlivable shootings and intimidation are the order of the day and will only increase due to the soft policy.




If you can believe the people at customs, we have long since lost the drug war and waiting for Mexican conditions, see the item on the news of 10-1-2023.



You can no longer respond.

What are the current quotations?

View and compare prices and rates yourself

News Nitrogen

SSC fully opposes Brabant's stable policy

Opinions Krijn J. Poppe

Back to basics: 250 years of (agricultural) economics

Opinions Arjan Ausma

Look ahead without losing vision under grids

Background Economy

Extensive livestock farmers receive considerably more than arable farmers

Call our customer service +0320(269)528

or mail to support@boerenbusiness.nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Sign up