Bill approved

France to ban vegetarian meat

4 May 2018 - Wouter Baan - 25 comments

Vegetarian meat and dairy substitutes can no longer be linked to meat or dairy in France. Last week, the French Parliament decided that names such as vegetarian sausages and cheeses are no longer allowed.

The bill, recently approved, was introduced by Jean Baptiste Moreau (member of President Macron's ruling LREM party). Baptiste Moreau is a cattle farmer in the Creuse region, which is located in the center of France. The politician believes that animal meat should not be associated with vegetarian or vegan meat substitutes.

Fines up to €300.000

The new legislation is subject to strict rules. For example, fines can amount to €300.000 if manufacturers of vegetarian meat substitutes do not adjust the packaging. 

Also discussion in the Netherlands and Germany
The 'schnitzelgate discussion' also plays a role in the Netherlands and Germany. This is what the VVD wanted at the beginning of 2017 a ban on a meat name for meat substitutes, while the CDA already raised the discussion at an earlier stage. The Dutch Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority also found that the 'Vegetarian Butcher' had to change its product names. The food watchdog later came back to the ruling, because of the fuss that followed.  

In Germany, Christian Schmidt, former Minister of Agriculture, wanted to ban vegetarian meat denominations. In contrast to France, the proposals did not go through in Germany in the Netherlands.

Do you have a tip, suggestion or comment regarding this article? Let us know

Wouter Job

Wouter Baan is editor-in-chief of Boerenbusiness. He also focuses on dairy, pig and meat markets. He also follows (business) developments within agribusiness and interviews CEOs and policymakers.
Comments
25 comments
Paul 4 May 2018
This is a response to this article:
[url=http://www.boerenbusiness.nl/varkens-feed/ artikel/10878451/frankrijk-gaat-vegetarisch-vlees-verbiden][/url]
Now the Netherlands..
Subscriber
EU 4 May 2018
Strange that there are no European guidelines for this
Ruben 4 May 2018
This really isn't a conflict of interest.. A cattle farmer who submitted a political ban against vegetarian meat
Lia 4 May 2018
Ridiculous. Plant-based is the future. Animal-corpse is out of fat. It's disgusting how politicians keep showing their prejudiced boyfriends servant faces over and over again.
Subscriber
info 4 May 2018
Lia you really miss the mark meat is meat and lettuce is lettuce and fake meat or lettuce should have a specific name . We also do not call a nail a hammer while the nail has to be driven into the wood by the hammer. Sorry Lia
Aldes 4 May 2018
I would say: then the NVWA will have a hard time with all those renamings where there is no connection with the 'product': sla finches, beef tomatoes, etc.
And milk is not strictly animal. Thistles, dandelions etc. also give milk.
Just admit you're losing. Admittedly, it may take a while, but the livestock industry is doomed.
Iris 5 May 2018
I can't wait for the day when the last livestock farm has to close its doors
Jan 5 May 2018
@Iris, For some it's time for war
happy piglet 5 May 2018
iris wrote:
I can't wait for the day when the last livestock farm has to close its doors
I don't know how old you will be but one thing I know for sure you will not experience this.
Marleen 5 May 2018
Time for war: hope you will be the first to be taken down. Loser.
curly tail 5 May 2018
I feel like one person is responding to multiple names...
Erika 5 May 2018
Really no conflict of interest, a politician who supposedly fights for the animals, then lets the animals in the OVP, and also takes no action against the soy meat that is called sausage. Tadaaaa, and there came the rabbit out of the top hat, her (ex) husband produces that mess!
john 5 May 2018
I am sure that if we put meat products with vegetable names on the vegetable shelf, all hell will break loose. An ultimate stunt of course. :D
Erika 5 May 2018
Really no conflict of interest, a politician who supposedly fights for the animals, then lets the animals in the OVP, and also takes no action against the soy meat that is called sausage. Tadaaaa, and there came the rabbit out of the top hat, her (ex) husband produces that mess!
down below 5 May 2018
Reuben wrote:
This really isn't a conflict of interest.. A cattle farmer who submitted a political ban against vegetarian meat


where is a ban against vegetarian meat filed?
It is the name that is banned.
Subscriber
info 5 May 2018
We still live in a free country and everyone will decide what we eat and whether that is meat or vegetables they are all created by cell division and whether we cut off spinach or slaughter an animal we deprive that product of its ability to live on. When we look in nature, animals die in the same way and are totally eaten by other animals and the moisture that is released is taken up as food by plants to grow from it, what is it that keeps people busy in battle against this natural course of events.
Aad 6 May 2018
Meat is the past.
The transition that is taking place now, with all the last convulsions of the meat industry, is the present.
100% vegetable is the future.

Get used to it.
curly tail 6 May 2018
0.5% of the Dutch population is vegan and 4.5% is vegetarian. In addition, meat consumption has been rising again since the Netherlands has emerged from the recession. What are we talking about?
Henk 6 May 2018
Compare intensive livestock farming where an animal is seen as a product and please do not treat it with nature.
has 6 May 2018
herbivore eat vegetarian
carnivore eats meat
omnivore eats both.
that's how biology works.
I don't interfere with the other.
the other does not interfere with me.
everything solved.
Subscriber
info 6 May 2018
How some people suffer from a sick mind and try to carry 95% of humanity in their illness. Man has been eating meat for as long as he has existed and that will never change.
Marc 7 May 2018
Meat is meat and lettuce is lettuce, which is why a recipe with ground beef and bacon is called slavink ????
Marc's meat 7 May 2018
While we're on the subject of beef. How many people know that Hamburger comes from Hamburg and has nothing to do with ham (pork) in some hamburger recipes there is some bacon but other than that it is beef. Are we now going to ban Mcdonalds and Burger King etc. from using the word "Ham" burger??,
Marc 7 May 2018
Hamburger (
to be pronounced "Hemburker") became "Burger". Later the variations followed cheeseburger : cheese and beef,
but also the fish burger, only fish, "burger" became synonymous with the disc: so there is absolutely nothing wrong with calling such an edible "disk" vegetarian burger if it is vegetarian.
Marc 7 May 2018
Rope-makers, copper-smiths and, indeed, butchers existed and still exist. We have called the latter a butcher's shop for convenience, but that really only means that "something" is "beaten". Since butcher does not mean meat lager by definition, you should be able to call your shop vegetarian "butcher shop"
Marc 7 May 2018
And what should we do with non-alcoholic beer? That is no more "beer" than fries without potatoes are fries. The difference is that all major beer brands have a successful product with them, so there is no one you will hear complaining about the naming.
You can no longer respond.

What do the current
pigs & feed quotations

View and compare prices and rates yourself

Call our customer service +0320 - 269 528

or mail to supportboerenbusiness. Nl

do you want to follow us?

Receive our free Newsletter

Current market information in your inbox every day

Login/Register